Father Christmas called on me early this week

This morning I got a phone call from Ming – promoting me to the shadow cabinet as International Development spokeswoman. A nice early Christmas present! It’ll be a bit of a wrench leaving home affairs, as being number two in the team there has been a great job, but I’m looking forward to the challenges of the new job – especially as in these inter-connected days, what happens overseas so often ends up having an impact back home.

(More on the other moves is on the party website and on Liberal Democrat Voice).

Review of the year

Co-presented Iain Dale’s Review of the Year on internet TV – 18 Doughty Street. It was, in the end, mostly about international affairs – which given my promotion earlier in the day was quite appropriate. My new job will place me in the International Affairs Team with Foreign Affairs and Defence. The discussion ranged over Iraq, Israel and Lebanon etc – and I think I went too far in terms of being non-partisan, as in fact it was Iain who raised the Lib Dem noble position on the Iraq war. Though perhaps it’s an interesting and possibly new approach for politicians: if you don’t state the bleeding obvious – others feel obliged to do it for you? So – I found the panel (Peter Riddell, Keith Simpson and Danny Finkelstein) all acknowledging the Liberal Democrat moral (and right) position against the war in Iraq. We ranged over Gordon, Dave, Tony and Ming – and then amazingly an hour and a half had passed.

Don't target the innocent

I am sick of the good guys being the fall guys. Let me elucidate. At its most simple it’s that honest, good citizens (the good guys) who transgress, for let’s say, staying on a parking meter or pay and display a few minutes over time get a ticket – and pay it.

The bad guys – who perhaps don’t bother to find a meter and park illegally and get a ticket or are involved in a traffic incident or so on – by contrast frequently don’t pay. And the worse they are, the less likely they are to pay – because they’ve not got up-to-date car tax, not got insurance, not got a license, given a fake address, using a stolen car, can’t be traced via the DVLA or because of any of 101 other reasons.

It all amounts to the more honest you are, the more likely you are to be punished if you make a mistake or have a momentary lapse of judgement. Don’t get me wrong – I am a great supporter of proper traffic and parking regulations – and if we park illegally we should be done for it and pay up – but the rules have to be fair and they have to be right. But the zealous – often over-zealous – chasing up of people who are easy to find whilst others can escape completely means we have the opposite of how a fair and just system should work. Good guys get the punishment, bad guys escape. Yes, punish people if they break the rules, but punish people more severely the worse their actions.

Even worse, those who aren’t easy to trace because of the tax and insurance etc dodges are often flouting not just those rules but, on the too rare occasions they are caught, turn out to be wanted for a host of other offences too. Pursuing the habitual wrong-doers would therefore reduce all sorts of misdeeds and clean up a whole range of misdemeanours.

So – you would think – that the authorities would invest in catching the bad guys. But think back through the recent government announcements and ideas – spying on people’s litter bins, mandatory national ID cards, introducing a database of all the phone calls and emails in this country – and they’re all ones that involve putting huge resources into keeping tabs on innocent people.

Rather than really going after the people they should be pursuing, time and again the government goes for the petty authoritarianism of wanting to keep even more tabs on innocent people.

We need to rebalance the system – and that includes holding to account those who make mistakes that end up harassing the innocent.

Only recently, one Haringey Councillor went public on the fact that two yellow junction boxes in the borough were illegal – yet hundreds of people have been ticketed from those junctions. (By the way: if you know of any more instances where there is bad signing or illegal markings – let me know.)

Haven’t heard Haringey Council announce refunds to all those good guys who did nothing wrong and paid up. And perhaps local authorities should be fined for tickets that are wrongly issued or are the consequence of poor or confusing signage – that would give a real incentive to get rules right and to treat everyone fairly. And what could be better than that?

(c) Lynne Featherstone, 2008

Christmas message

As I write this Christmas message, it is a stunningly mild December day and the hottest year on record since records began – a seemingly scary reminder of the threat to our world. So as we go into the Christmas break – there are two issues that ricochet around my brain – the two great challenges I believe the world faces – climate change and living together.

There have been many important local issues this year – from Hornsey Town Hall, to the dreadful planning permissions granted at appeal for the Concrete Factory in Stroud Green and poorly designed high density flats in Wood Green We’ve seen the completion of the roll-out of Safer Neighbourhood Police Teams across the borough and the fight to get a decent new health facility on the old Hornsey Central Hospital site. There has been the usual debacle of lack of school places and we are almost at the point of handing over of Ally Pally – who knows what that will bring?

But it is these two great challenges – or threats to our world – that we need to focus on in the year ahead. We can all make a difference to climate change if each of us does our little bit to reduce our own carbon footprint – and that we should do without questions.

But the shadow of 7/7 has fallen across our land and there is a schism developing between different peoples. We must, in Haringey, make sure that we hold hands across any such divide and send our thoughts too to the people in particular of the Middle East and Africa – the people of Lebanon, Palestine, Israel, Iraq, Afghanistan and Darfur.

At this time of year – let there really be peace on earth and good will to everyone.

TV appearances

I’m co-presenting with Iain Dale on 18 Doughty Street TV again on Monday for a review of the year – so that should be fun!

I’ve been bumped off the Sunday Edition today. They phoned on Friday to book me saying they would phone back on Saturday. With no call back, I called them to discover that I had been bumped. This happens from time to time – and I am reasonably amenable and philosophic about being at the end of the food chain – but no call back is bad manners. Other programs do manage good manners!

How council group leaders are elected

Over at Should party members get a say in the election of council group leaders?Liberal Review I’ve got an article on how we (Liberal Democrats) elect the leaders of our council groups. In brief:

Even where there is real choice and disagreement – and where the result determines who heads up a council, one of the most important political jobs there is – party members do not get a say.

From what I know of the rules in other parties too, the idea that a council group leader is elected only by their fellow councillors is pretty common. Yet (particularly in the Liberal Democrats), the people who end up running councils are the public office holders with some of the most power and greatest ability to have an impact on the outside world. I’ve taken part in elections of the whole local party’s membership to decide who will get to vote at the party’s conferences – but when I was a council group leader myself (in Haringey), party members were not part of the process. As I say in the piece, I have some doubts about whether this is right.

To pick up on a couple of the comments on the discussion over on Liberal Review – I don’t think the rules need be as complicated as they are for our Parliamentary candidate selection (to be a group leader you’d need to already be a councillor and so already gone through an approval and selection process anyway) and I don’t see cost as being a big issue – local parties should be writing to their members at least once a year anyway (I hope!), so any ballot could be part of an existing mailing.

Anyway – read the piece for yourself and tell me what you think!

CROUCH END COUNCILLOR WELCOMES BURGLARY FIGURES REDUCTION BUT EXPRESSES CONCERN OVER THEFT FROM MOTOR VEHICLES

Liberal Democrat councillor Lyn Weber has warmly welcomed the news that burglary figures for the Crouch End ward in the London Borough of Haringey are going down. At a recent Safer Neighbourhoods Team meeting it was revealed that residential burglaries were down from 145 cases to 78 in the year to date.

“While not for a moment detracting from the terrible effect on the victims of burglary, and the still disturbing total number of offences, it is good news that criminal damage, common assault, wounding, theft of motor vehicles and motor vehicle interference – are all going down,” said Lyn.

With the winter months now well upon us, Crouch End councillors sounded a note of caution, with the news that theft from motor vehicles has increased. Cllr Weber is asking everyone to think about the risk of crime, and not leave property in cars that could attract thieves.

She adds: “We all need to take police advice – and reduce the risk of property theft by removing satellite navigation systems, Christmas presents – and anything else which is on view in your car for the common thief who just can’t resist. Take your gear with you – and let’s spoil the thief’s Christmas for a change.”

LIB DEM OUTRAGE AT BRUSH OFF FROM HEWITT

With growing concerns over local NHS services, Haringey’s Liberal Democrat councillors are fuming at a letter received from a junior official in response to a letter from Haringey’s Overview and Scrutiny Committee to the Health Secretary, Patricia Hewitt. The terse reply was signed by an official from a Customer Care Centre

Haringey’s Overview and Scrutiny Committee had written to the Minister to draw attention to the severe pressure being put on the Haringey Primary Care Trust (PCT) by the London Strategic Health Authority, which is regularly dipping into PCT budgets to bail out London Acute Hospital Trusts. Services have been cut, staff moral is low and there are fears of more cuts being made in a borough with some of the most intense pockets of deprivation in the UK.

The response has cause anger, with its dismissive tone and refusal to address any of the central issues raised by the Committee.

Lib Dem Health spokesperson Cllr Richard Wilson comments:

“Haringey experiences severe health inequalities and it is impossible for the PCT to provide and plan for services in this uncertain financial climate. Millions have already been grabbed from their budget with more on the way next year. Hewitt’s response demonstrates the contempt this Labour Government has for the people that pay for the NHS”.

Cllr David Winskill, who drafted the original letter, adds:

“To get what looks like a stock reply from someone in a Customer Service Centre is appalling. Residents in Haringey have the right to expect ministers to take their concerns seriously. Colleagues on Overview and Scrutiny were genuinely shocked at the patronising tone and brevity of the response.”

LIB DEM ANGER AT INDEFINITE CLOSURE OF MUSWELL HILL YOUTH CLUB

A local Liberal Democrat councillor has expressed dismay that Haringey’s Labour run council has closed Muswell Hill Youth Club until further notice due to staff shortages.

This closure also comes shortly after the highly critical Ofsted Report into Haringey Youth Service, which labelled it ‘inadequate’ and the range of provision ‘unsatisfactory’, awarding it with a Grade 1 -‘a service that does not deliver minimum requirements for users.’

Cllr Gail Engert (Muswell Hill ward) comments:

“It beggars belief that this Labour Council cannot provide staff to keep open the only youth facility that Haringey provides in the west of the borough. This is particularly shocking after the damning Ofsted Report on Haringey youth services that raises serious concerns borough-wide.

“Closing the youth centre so there is nowhere for young people to go just leaves the police to pick up the pieces of youth disaffection. Local Lib Dem councillors are continually highlighting the lack of youth provision in their wards but under this Labour administration instead of getting better, things are only getting worse.”

Friday round-up

Meeting constituents to go through their issues all morning at Wood Green library. It has had a makeover – and the room I hold my surgery in is now really great. It has armchairs and sofas, a new floor, table and the atmosphere is a million times more conducive to making people feel more comfortable. Before it was cluttered with tables and chairs of the very utilitarian variety.

Am still incandescent about our Government dropping the investigation into Saudi deal. With jobs and the future security of our nation given as the reason for the moral position holding no sway, it is depressing to find out we are as bad as everyone else.

Then, thank goodness (as by now I need to lighten up) it’s off to my staff Christmas lunch and we go to a Crouch End restaurant that I had never been to before – Aix. Fantastic meal – and the desert was to die for! I rarely eat desert – but Ed (in charge of running my constituency office and my diary) recommended ice cream with honeycomb – yum!