Whittington A&E – Story 14

Olivia’s story:

I feel very strongly about the threatened closure of A & E at Whittington. This is partly for all the reasons put forward by others – the ridiculousness of the Royal Free being able to cope with increased numbers, the journey time from places like Crouch End or Hornsey (even Highgate) and the nightmare of Pond Street and parking (not good even at Whittington but nothing like as bad as Pond Street). 

My other reason is that my father was a consultant at Whittington many years ago and the coronary care unit there is named after him (Montuschi Ward).  He would have said that an A & E is essential to a vibrant, living hospital that is at the heart of a community.
Without an A & E a general hospital becomes a large edifice with little connection to the people around it.

On a more personal note, when our daughter Susannah was suspected of having meningitis some years ago the service and care she received in A & E and then on the paediatric ward were second to none.

The hospital was part of my family life and childhood and later, when Walter and I moved from Kentish Town to Highgate, two of our three children were born there.  It feels really important to me that for all it’s shortcomings (and there are very few A & E departments in London that anyone would really choose to attend) Whittington A & E remains available to the people of this very mixed part of North London.

Whittington consultants come out against closure proposals!

All the consultants at the Whittington have come out publicly against the proposed closure of the A&E. Hopefully this will be the nail in the Labour Government’s coffin of their Health Care for London plan! The Minister in the debate I secured last Wednesday banged on about how this was all clinically led. This is the clinical fightback  – clearly the plans have no support whatsoever from the Whittington consultants.

Public statement by the consultants of The Whittington Hospital NHS Trust

March 2010

The North Central London Strategy Plan (25 January 2010) has made proposals for the development of health services in North Central London over the next four years.  The Strategy Plan, which is being considered by the Joint Committee of Primary Care Trusts, puts forward seven different potential scenarios for the reconfiguration of hospital services within North Central London. Four of these seven scenarios involve either restricting the opening times of The Whittington accident and emergency department, or closing it completely. Closure of the accident and emergency department would by necessity lead to the shutting down of all emergency medical and surgical services at the Whittington.

We, the consultants of The Whittington Hospital, are completely committed to retaining a high quality full, 24/7 accident and emergency department at The Whittington.

We have no doubt that retaining a full accident and emergency at The Whittington is in the best interests of the people in North Central London. Eighty three thousand adults and children a year attend our accident and emergency department at all hours for their health needs, and fifteen thousand people a year are admitted as emergencies to our hospital. In national comparisons of hospitals across the country, The Whittington Hospital has consistently performed superbly. In October 2009 the Care Quality Commission, the independent regulator of health in England, confirmed our hospital’s good quality of services and excellent financial management. In November 2009 the annual Dr Foster Quality Account, which ranks every hospital trust in England, identified the Whittington one of the safest hospitals in the country, giving an overall rating for the Whittington as 21st out of 145 hospitals. We are immensely proud of the excellent emergency services that we offer to our local people, and we are determined that they should continue.

We fully support the aims of the 2007 Healthcare for London report A Framework for Actionwhich seeks to promote excellence and remove inequalities in healthcare for the people of London. We also fully recognise the need for the NHS to optimise the efficiency and productivity of its services in the current economic climate. We welcome the opportunity to work in the future with our managers and The Trust Board, our neighbouring hospitals and the primary care trusts to continue to develop and improve the excellent services that we already offer to our local people.

Dr Ben Timmis FRCR

Chairman of The Whittington Hospital Support Committee

on behalf of all the consultants at The Whittington Hospital NHS Trust

Labour sleaze

I am horrified by ex Labour Minister Stephen Byer’s touting for dosh using his ‘connections’. My goodness – we are trying to get free of the horrific scandal of MP expenses and regain peoples’ trust – and then this! And from three MPs who are stepping down – so clearly they are only interested in themselves and what they can get out of their ex-status.

Normally in firms – there is a two year contract to not open up in the same business in the same area (or variations on) when you leave the company. Surely – at the very least – the same should apply to politicians. 

This is sleaze plain and simple – and Labour’s suggestion that a ‘register’ of lobbyists is the answer is pathetic. It is quite clear that it has been possible to buy legislative influence and change during Labour’s reign – that should not be possible!

I, and am sure most other MPs, meet and are lobbied by organisations all the time – and of course they want us to see things their way. When I was Shadow Sec of State for International Development – there were hundreds of them all wanting this or that. But listening to informed people in the field put their point is one thing and totally legitimate and if I’m lucky, informative too.

However, being paid must be a crime?

Local MP gets health minister to confirm – no clinical case for closing the Whittington A&E

In a debate in Parliament on Wednesday, Liberal Democrat MP Lynne Featherstone got agreement from the Health Minister that there is no clinical case for closing the Whittington A&E.

After putting a very strong case for why the Whittington A&E must stay open in the debate in Westminster Hall, the Hornsey and Wood Green MP got Health Minister Mike O’Brien to confirm that the £30million invested in the Whittington would be wasted and that a clinical case for closing it had not been made.

To read the full debate see here or to view it see here.

Lynne Featherstone, MP for Hornsey and Wood Green comments:

“The Health Minister confirms what we have said all along – there is no case for closing the Whittington A&E and doing so would be sheer and utter madness.

“But I’m worried that these may be just warming words. We cannot and must not relax until we’ve seen the back of these proposals – hands off our A&E.”

Better battery recycling in Haringey

Here’s my latest column for the Muswell Hill Flyer and the Highgate Handbook:

Recycling batteriesI try to be good with recycling – but when it comes to batteries it is sometimes quite difficult because there isn’t an easy and convenient place to put them locally.

We have battery recycling bins at Parliament – so that makes it easy for me. But how many of us do bother to take batteries to the recycling centres? I don’t know – but I suspect the odd one or two just gets put in the normal rubbish.

So – I just wanted to tell you about a success my Liberal Democrat colleagues on Haringey Council had in the budget debate. Haringey Council agreed to implement Liberal Democrats plans that will provide new green incentives and better recycling in the borough.

My LibDem colleagues proposed that Haringey Council provide new battery recycling services in libraries, community buildings and schools, and new green incentives for local traders and residents to move to ‘greener’ vehicles by reducing parking fees for the least polluting cars.

Even better – the new measures will be paid for by freezing allowances for councillors to the tune of £14,000!

This follows fast on the heals of the new rules passed by the European Union which mean that as of February 2010 shops must have battery recycling bins for residents to use if they sell the equivalent of 1 pack a day. It makes it so much easier to be good – if there is a facility for us to recycle things like batteries easily available. I went to a Tesco local next to my office in Hornsey High Street to celebrate their new battery recycling facilities installed to meet the EU rules.

Until now, people who wanted to do the right thing had to make their way to one of Haringey’s two recycling centres – and that’s not the best way to encourage recycling of some of our most hazardous waste. Batteries are so bad for the environment, and most people do want to do their bit for our planet – it’s only right to make it as easy as possible for people to do just that.

As an added bonus: in terms of encouraging greener vehicles – Haringey Council agreed to the LibDem proposals that there would be free parking for the greenest business vehicles and free parking for the greenest residents’ vehicles.

Hurrah!

Whittington A&E – Story 12

Alice’s story:

Over the 16 years that I’ve lived in the area, I’ve had to use the A&E at Whittington Hospital on several occasions.  Having an A&E just a short bus ride away makes all the difference; when you’re in a situation that requires attention at an A&E, you don’t necessarily have the presence of mind to take everything you need with you.  I’ve had to take both my son and daughter to the A&E at Whittington Hospital and it is just a comfort to know that if we need to fetch anything from home for them like a teddy or pyjamas then we won’t be away from them for long.  I’ve also been grateful for an A&E being close by on the two occasions when I had miscarriages and while waiting in A&E is never a particularly pleasant experience, knowing that I wasn’t also miles away from home was reassuring.  I hate to think how much worse it would have been had I needed to travel many extra miles just to get to an A&E department.

Liberal Democrats demand action as CCTV post remains vacant

Liberal Democrat Crime Spokesperson Cllr Ron Aitken has demanded action after it was revealed that a key Haringey Council crime-fighting post has been left vacant for several months.

Minutes from Haringey’s Safer Communities Executive Board (18 February 2010) show that the post of CCTV Manager has been vacant for several months at a time when residents have been demanding measures to tackle crime and anti-social behaviour. The funds allocated for the post have been used to provide temporary cover, but the Liberal Democrats say the lack of a permanent post-holder has caused other initiatives to be stalled.

Cllr Ron Aitken, Liberal Democrat Crime Spokesperson, comments:

“The lack of a permanent CCTV Manager is affecting other aspects of Haringey Council’s crime-fighting strategy.

“For example, a request by the Queen’s Road Neighbourhood Watch for a CCTV camera, to watch a notorious crime spot near Bowes Park over-ground station, was turned down.”

Lynne Featherstone, MP for Hornsey and Wood Green adds:

“It’s really worrying that for months there has been no permanent staff member in such a crucial post – the effective use of CCTV does not simply depend on the cameras but on the people who manage and monitor them.

“With evidence that other aspects of the crime fighting strategy may be suffering as a result, Haringey Council needs to get its act together and recruit a permanent member of staff as soon as possible.”

Whittington A&E – Story 12

Sarah’s story:

I am desperately worried that there is a possibility Whittington A&E could close. As the mother of one-and-a-half-year old twin boys, I suspect I will be needing to use it.

I have visited A&E twice in the last two years, once due to possible miscarriage and once due to illness of one of my babies. Both times I was treated well.

Since I don’t own a car, on these occasions I tried to get a taxi, but none were available for 30 mins and so I travelled to A&E by bus getting there door-to-door in 20 mins. If I were to have to travel to the Royal Free it would be impossible by public transport (taking perhaps an hour as it’s 2 or 3 buses) and by taxi would take a lot longer and it’s likely I wouldn’t have enough money in the house for much higher fare – stopping off at a cash machine would be another detour and more time wasted. Realistically, I can imagine having to call an ambulance as the only way to get to A&E even if the incident was not life-threatening. As for a life-threatening incident the extra travel time by ambulance or car is even more worrying.

Please remember that not everyone has a car or can afford long taxi journeys in the middle of the night.

I am also seriously worried about the implication that other services could be moved away. Getting to the Royal Free would be very difficult from where I live. I have already have to leave a course of treatment at St Anne’s Hospital in Tottenham because it takes 1 hour 15 mins each way and I have two young babies. Not being able to access other treatments currently available at the Whittington would be a big problem.

It would have been traumatic to take the tube to use UCH instead of the Whittington for maternity services , or example, as by the end of my pregnancy I could barely walk yet had to attend several times a week.

I’m no one important, just a mum, but I hope my opinion counts.

Free to be Young

At the Liberal Democrat conference last weekend, I moved the motion on our new youth policy paper, Free to be Young. Here’s my speech:

When Nick Clegg gave me the Youth portfolio – we agreed that Liberal Democrats would be relentlessly pro-youth – not anti-youth!

Young people often get a raw deal. When they work hard and pass their exams – all they hear is that they only did well because tests are getting easier these days.

And although young people are more likely to be a victim of crime than any other group in society – politicians – Labour and Tory obviously – and the media often treat them as though they are all criminals.

And when there is nothing to do after school, because youth services have been decimated over the last two decades – then they are blamed for hanging around the streets.

The pressure comes at young people from so many angles:

  • from the medial who are happy to report on the kids who do cause trouble but never seem to give those same column inches to all the volunteering and good things that young people do; and
  • from the fashion, beauty and diet industry – who bombard young people with fake images and we know that  issues of low self esteem, anxiety and eating disorders are on the rise – directly correlated to this unremitting diet of over-perfected stereo types.

There are huge challenges ahead, particularly as we climb out of a recession that threatens young hopes and aspirations. If we don’t want a lost generation – then we have to make sure that we deliver a worthwhile future for our young people.

We Liberal Democrats are committed to creating a country where our young people can be free to be themselves, enabling them to be the very best they can be – and enjoy equal life chances with everyone else.

We want our policies to be effective – not vindictive.

That is why our youth policy paper, Free to be Young,  sets out what Liberal Democrats would do differently to provide a fresh start for young people in the UK today.

Families and relationships are so important – but we know that sometimes things don’t work out – and children see little of their fathers.

It’s not a tax break for married couples that are needed – it is about engaging both parents with their children regardless of who the child lives with.

We propose a program called Dads and Doughnuts.

And if both parents are not involved – we have to make an effort to facitlitate that involvement. We know that if fathers read with their sons at an early age – that child does much better. Dads and Doughnuts is about encouraging schools to involve both parents in their children’s lives – separately if necessary.

In employment – what message does it send to young people when they do the same job, the same hours – but receive a lower minimum wage?

That isn’t about fairness – that’s about doing it on the cheap.

And young people can get married and have children at sixteen, serve in the armed forces – pay tax. What was that about no taxation without representation? So we believe that young people should be able to vote at 16.

And as I said – the recession focuses our proposals on ensuring that we don’t have a lost generation.

We need to ensure that every young person has a pathway – whether that is work experience, training or education.

We will fund 15,000 more college based foundation degree places in the first year.

Introducing a new ‘paid internship scheme for the first year after the election paying a training allowance of £55 (£5 more than jobseekers) per week.

Because how do you persuade an employer that you can do the job if you have no work experience in that field – and how do you get that experience if you cannot get a job.

And freedom – what freedom is there on being on the DNA database when you are innocent?

I remember a young black mother coming to my surgery almost hysterical with worry because her young son, 11, had been playing hide and seek in the grounds of a local hospital.

A policeman stopped him and asked what he was doing (his mates ran off) and from that his DNA was taken and despite the fact he did nothing really wrong – he was just playing – that DNA record was held.

His mother was hysterical because she knows that one day an employer may ask if he is on the DNA database – and that record albeit for nothing – may add to the already difficult challenge in getting a job. Moreover – it is just wrong to hold records on innocent children.

We would remove them from the DNA database unless there is a conviction for violent or sexual offence.

Homophobic bullying is rife in our schools – we know that 6 out of 10 children are homophobically bullied.

Nick Clegg has spoken out about the need for teachers to talk about being gay – so that young people understand that it is just another way of being – another normal way of being. We will ensure better training and guidance for teachers and youth workers.

Lastly – because I believe there may be a call for a separate vote on the statutory duty – I urge you to support the motion as is. Liberal Democrats are not natural allies of statutory duties –– so whilst we might very well want to remove a whole raft of statutory duties if we could – but we are where we are – and because youth services in many authorities have been decimated over the last two decades we will make Youth Services a statutory responsibility.

We desperately need an army of youth workers with the commitment, energy and experience to work with our young people – and when the media charge young people with hanging around with nothing to do – much of that is to do with their budgets being raided by a cash-strapped authority.

We have to throw a protective ring around them if we are serious about investing in young people.

So – there isn’t time to cover all that is in the motion – let alone the policy paper.

I would like to take this opportunity to thank all the young people who took part in the consultation stages of this paper – bright, caring, and passionate and involved – nothing like the picture the media paints.

I would also like to thank Laura Willoughby who chaired the initial stages, and the members of the policy working group who were enthusiastic and determined that this would be a paper that enabled young people to breathe again.

And lastly Linda Jack – who chaired the Policy Working Group with experience, energy and commitment and a resolute determination that this paper should be positive and encouraging – and the title ‘Free to be Young’ is a reflection of the Liberal Democrat belief that every young person should feel that there is a decent, happy and fulfilling life ahead of them.

Thank you.