All power to Charles Clarke

First day in committee leading on the Police and Justice Bill – or the ‘I’m Charles Clark – I’m in charge Bill’ as much of it takes powers away from local bodies and puts it straight in the Home Sec’s hands. The first part of the Bill is about the merging of two central functions agencies into one new one – the National Police Improvement Agency. We don’t have too much trouble with that – however the next section (Schedule 2) is a real humdinger.

The first part of this is where the Home Secretary takes powers to decide how many members there are, what qualifications or disqualifications they have, what work is done and who chairs and vice chairs local Police Authorities. Centralisation or what? And they have gotten rid of magistrate members. I suspect magistrates know too much and give the Home Sec too much trouble. Ms Blears, Minister for Police etc, swears blind that this is all for our own good – saying the Government has a responsibility to make sure that everything is done properly and if things go wrong to go straight in and sort it out – without the hassle of any democratic processes or checks and balances in the way.

In the evening I go to Haringey City Growth Business Awards. It is a really delightful evening. I have been sent my little bit of script, a bit of blurb, for presenting on of the award. So I go up – and after I have said ‘and the winner is’ as I open the envelope (I can’t help myself admitting that I’ve always wanted to do that bit!) – I read out that the winner is Tracey Proudlock of Proudlock Associates. Tracey is a fabulous local woman – in a wheelchair – who really gets on with it. I am really glad she won the category.

Education Bill

Education Bill day today! And we fail to defeat the Government – but only because the Tories decide to prop them up. What kills me is the amount of time and effort spent on moving the deck-chairs – this Bill is all about structures not education and we have over 180 children who don’t even have a place at secondary school in Haringey. What a load of nonsense!

Rush back to Haringey where the Haringey Lib Dems are selecting prospective candidates for the local elections. I don’t get there until around 9pm as they are just finishing. All went well – and we now have our prospective candidates for the wards. Looking forward to the campaign – it will be a real contest with Labour’s decades long grip on the council under real threat at last!

Crime scam in Haringey

I received an email from a local resident who had experienced a con-man attempt and who asked that I publicise it in case anyone else might be caught by it. So thank you to my constituent and this is his tale.

The gentleman received a knock on the door from a woman purporting to be a neighbour who had just got home by taxi and did not have the £18.00 fare. She didn’t convince him and she left empty handed. At the time he couldn’t decide if it was genuine or a con. He thought about contacting the police but did not in case it was a genuine plea for help. Of course that is what the con men and women are preying on.

On Tuesday this gentleman had a visit by the local uniformed officers who asked if he had been approached in the manner above and, therefore, confirming that it was a confidence trick. He felt that they will obviously move on to different area of the borough so it might be worth warning people through my means of communications.
You have been warned!

Today is the debate on animal welfare and finally I get to vote against tail-docking of dogs. I have no hesitation – despite arguments about working dogs needing to be exempt. It’s fashion for the most part – and cruel!

Another phone call from Ming’s office – and I am now also London Spokesperson!

Brian Paddick

In the evening I am sponsoring and speaking in a panel debate on the clash between journalists/photographers and the police. The panel is meant to be an MP from each of the main parties – Boris Johnson, Austin Mitchell and myself – plus Assistant Police Commissioner Brian Paddick. However, the chair informs me as I arrive that both Boris and Austin have pulled out – leaving me and Brian. Well – it was quite a ‘feisty’ evening! Brian has rewritten the guidelines for police handling of media – because of the clashes, confiscations of equipment and altercations. The rewriting has some good points, but several journos gave personal accounts of mistreatment by the police – thus putting Brian on the spot. In the end, he accepted that officers do not always walk the talk on such things. Of course, guidelines, as I pointed out, are all very well – it’s ensuring that officers at the sharp end observe them. I still think there is a long way to go – and the bad news is that Brian is retiring in the near future.

And when I think of my time seeing the Met up close when I served on the Metropolitan Police Authority (MPA) for five year – Brian is the one officer I met who I believe really understands and gives weight to some of the problems that are contentious. From his avant garde approach to cannabis when he was commander in Lambeth, to his evidence to the stop and search scrutiny and subsequent work on that within the Met and the guidelines as above. I don’t know who will be defender of these things in the Met when he goes.

Promotion

In the early evening, I get a message on my phone from Ming to say that he would like me to stay in the Home Affairs team as I had requested and would like me to be No2 (that’s one up from before!) – Deputy Shadow Home Secretary. Plus I get to keep the policing portfolio – so am delighted.

The business of the day is the ID cards debate on the Lords amendments. Starting for parliamentary procedure I don’t understand at 10pm which is when we usually finish on a Monday. The argument now is over the Government’s ridiculous assertion that the requirement to have a passport (with which you have to have an identity card) is voluntary. I should take Charles Clarke to a border and make him cross it without a passport. I’d love to see him arguing with the border guard that it is ‘voluntary’ as to whether you have a passport or not. Labour have gone completely mad. It was Nick Clegg’s debut proper speech as our Shadow Home Secretary – and he did really well. Nevertheless – the Government won by around 33 votes. The argument now goes back to the Lords where I hope they sling it out again. Of course – what will finally put a nail in the coffin will be the cost and how unpopular that it nearing an election. Bastards!

I also have to write an article on Education for the Ham & High Education Supplement – despite getting home very late – it’s not over ’til it’s over!

And my emails tell me that I have been nominated for the New Statesman New Media Awards for my website.

Good night!

Sir Ian Blair

Oh Sir Ian! Our police chief never ceases to have to apologise for putting his foot in it. On today’s news – the recording secretly of private conversations – you have to think that he is doing it for a reason. It may be, given the vulnerability of his position, he feels he needs back-up in case briefings against him begin (or continue). I think he is in trouble. And I think if the IPCC report looking at communications – subtext Ian Blair’s role and actions post Stockwell – find him wanting, then he’s probably a gonner.

It’s odd really. Knowing him from five years on the Met Police Authority when he was Deputy Commissioner – he so wanted this job. It must be like a nightmare for him for it all to go so off track so soon. It’s about trying to manage business and media – that’s his problem. And he has never been viewed as a ‘coppers’ copper’ the way Sir John Stevens was. And he is extremely political.

However, more to the local point, he has promised to come and discuss the future of police stations in Haringey – and that’s an important discussion. Not just for Haringey – but for the future of policing more generally. They have a natural tendency to centralise – and we the people know that we need police amongst us to be successful.

During the day I visit a group of residents in Dukes Avenue, who before humps were introduced in their street, were already desperate to stop lorries racing down their narrow residential street as a cut through. Since the humps have come – the noise and vibration is unbearable. I have already met with the senior traffic officers at Haringey to beg for action against the lorries – and although they say they agree, they want to wait for works on the North Circular etc before taking any action. However, with the humps, the problem is exacerbated. So this time, am taking another tack, and asking the Council what they need in way of evidence to take action. Is it number of trucks? Is it levels of noise? Is it damage to cars? Is it number of people in which roads supporting pinch points in two locations to simply stop the through lorries? We will see what the response is.

Shami Chakrabarti

Shami Chakrabarti and Lynne Featherstone MPBig annual social at my house. There is a huge turnout because our guest speaker is Shami Chakrabarti from Liberty. She is a complete star – comes early – stays late and entirely captivates the audience who are natural territory for Liberty. Many of my members are her members – and I think she recruits quite a few more by the end of play. Why does Shami work so well? I think it is because she hasn’t sold out to anyone. She really does fight for right and justice – and in a non-partisan way. And it’s interesting hearing her talk about the difference between coming to this event and similar ones organised by other parties!She can reach beyond the TV screen or radio direct into people’s lives because the language she uses and the pictures she paints with her words pull on people’s instincts and conscience.In the current climate of authoritarian governance there is a pressing need for all voices of freedom and human rights to rise up together as Labour continues its juggernaut assault on our civil liberties. Every Bill that I come across removes our rights and increases the power of the state. These are frightening times.    

Care and crime in the community

Rather a coincidence – after Friday’s launch of a new scheme involving Neighbourhood Watches, today I am giving a speech to the Haringey Borough Neighbourhood Watch AGM. I am talking about anti-social behaviour etc – but use the opportunity to have a rant about ‘care in the community’ or lack of it.

Part of my speech is about the importance of us all working to tackle crime:

“I would like to pay tribute to Neighbourhood Watches and all those who serve on them. The work they do is invaluable and beneficial and they create and forge a strong sense of community and looking out for each other, working with the police safer neighbourhood team, the Council’s anti-social behaviour teams and health partners is the way to go.

“Robert Peel, the founder of the Met once stated that: ‘the police are the public and the public are the police; the police being only members of the public who are paid to give fulltime attention to duties which are incumbent on every citizen in the interest of community welfare.’

“Fighting crime isn’t just something you can pay for through your taxes and can then ignore. It’s something that the whole of society has to do.”

I also talk about how it is both crime levels and fear of crime we need to concern ourselves with:

“Haringey Council’s own research indicates that crime is the number one concern of just under half (49%) of Haringey residents. However, crime levels, measured by the number of total notifiable offences is dropping – 19% down (5,346 fewer) than the same period last year.

“Even with this drop the figures are still high, but also it is often fear of crime and the experience of small misdemeanours as well as major crimes themselves that worries local residents and that most people contact me about. Far too often fear of crime is treated as if it isn’t really a proper problem to acknowledge – ‘oh the problem isn’t actual crime, it’s just people’s whipped up fears’ etc. But fear is real, it affects people, it hurts lives and it hinders freedom.”

Although crime is a much debated issue, I feel that one key aspect is talked about too little.

Part of anti-social behaviour that arises from people with mental health issues. Many of the cases I see of neighbour disputes are caused by mental health problems – not youths, not petty vandals – but people living in the community who have mental health issues and for whom the ‘care in the community’ package cannot be enough to watch over them 24 hours a day. There is a gap that people are falling through. More love and attention needs to be focused in this direction.

I am not talking about the major headline cases that burst, only occasionally but totally unacceptably, into our papers, when someone who should be in residential care is released and murders their next door neighbour – those are tragic cases which we all gasp at and wonder how such a person could be thought to be safely let amongst us. I am instead talking about the far less obvious cases.

It’s a difficult issue. But this gap in care – despite best efforts of those who work so tirelessly in this area – does lead to a chain of events or experiences – both for the person themselves and for those around them.

The person themselves can be shunned by their neighbours and feels depressed, upset and socially excluded and isolated – which helps not their situation.

Neighbours feel aggrieved that they live close to someone who behaves oddly, or aggressively and sometimes feel or are genuinely at risk of assault, or verbal abuse, or fear of arson or whatever. And the police cannot intervene before such an offence has been committed. This all means that such situations can get out of kilter and ratchet up the behaviour scale. In the end it is the police and the prisons that end up dealing with what is not – and should not be – their job. This is a health issue.

Think of it this way.

If you imagine a person with mental health issues lying in bed in hospital to be treated – you wouldn’t imagine a policeman being called on to intervene if such a patient starts shouting out and swearing at a nurse.

And yet – that is pretty much what is happening when such a person is out on our streets – the police are having to deal with what is reported as anti-social behaviour but which is an area of care or behaviour exhibiting as anti-social but in reality mental illness.

Tories and climate change

There’s a Private Members Bill on climate change coming up in Parliament today for which I am going in. So many constituents care passionately about this – that I have changed surgery etc (whose normal time would have clashed with the debate) to make it in.

But, having made great efforts to be there – I might as well not have bothered. Don’t get me wrong – the Bill should be supported. But the games played by the Tories to muck around by talking out, or putting stupid amendments, and threatening to keep doing so in order that we have to come every Friday to listen to rubbish being spouted is a disgrace to politics. It is a joke. And the waste of public money, Parliamentary time, Members’ time – not to mention the joke it makes of Private Members Bills is appalling.

I manage one vote after several hours of debate – or farce – and then have to leave to launch a new initiative by Haringey Neighbourhood Watch. They have organised with the Primary Care Trust (PCT) to put up their posters in every doctors’ waiting room in Haringey – so lots and lots of residents will see it. It is a good way to prevent crime and good to see health and crime and community all working together. So with two burly policemen and two doctors I put up the first poster!

Coroner troubles

First thing over to City Hall for private briefing on Operation Minstead. It was basically the same presentation that I had had some while back – and still they haven’t got their man. They are still painstakingly sifting through lists and lists of possible persons of interest. And all the DNA trawl in the world hasn’t yielded up the perpetrator. Will it ever? Leave in a rush as I have my session with Ming at 11.15am.

I go in and up to the office where Ming is ensconced with Archie Kirkwood – his political adviser. We have a very good discussion I thought. There is a little awkwardness around our different sides in the leadership election, but that’s natural. More interestingly I get a chance to discuss where I might want to be in the future and also, more importantly, to bung my two pennies in on the organisation and campaigning aspects of the Liberal Democrats. Hopefully they will let me keep policing!

At lunchtime, I go to a meeting where three women (partners or parents) of someone who has died have had the most appalling and tragic experience and the most horrific mistreatment by a coroner. It seems to me from the evidence presented that there is plenty of reason for a public enquiry into the cases that appear to have been so poorly, or negligently handled. Watch this space.

And out on the campaign trail knocking on doors for a good session – which restored my soul. It was so good, and happy and people were just nice, nice, nice.

PS If you watched Question Time tonight you will have noticed that Nick Clegg who I was bumped in favour of, was not there. On Tuesday or Wednesday this week – QT had decided they wanted to change back to me. Unfortunately, by this time I had made another arrangement. So they bumped Nick in favour of Jean Lambert, Green MEP. C’est la vie!