Hornsey Central Hospital

Off to the Three Compasses (my HQ) for a council of war on what is happening to health in this borough. The cuts are cutting now deeply. Five family planning units gone or going for example. The X-ray unit at St Ann’s saved – but many, many other front line services disappearing. And why? Because of this Labour government’s lack of understanding about how best to run the health service. They have flung a fortune at the health service – most of which has gone into poorly negotiated doctor and consultant contracts. Their budgeting regime has meant that if a Trust balances its budget (much of which is achieved by cuts) then the following year it must make more ‘efficiency savings’ so that it can give its ‘surplus’ to a Trust that has failed to keep to budget. It is theatre of the absurd. It demotivates the good Trusts and rewards the ‘bad’. Except that the ‘bad’ are those Trusts that ‘overspend’ – but overspending means that they are trying to meet need in the community where elsewhere they are cutting front line services – as here.

Amongst other things, we are meeting to kick off the arrangements for the campaign to force the pace on the progress (or lack of it) on Hornsey Hospital. After the meeting we go off to Hornsey Hospital to set up the campaign shots. It looks so forlorn these days with its closure notices. It is six years since we were promised that if we (residents and Lib Dem politicians) stopped our campaign to save the hospital – then the Trust would together with us to a create new health facility for the community. So we worked with the PCT. There were public meetings and plans and public meetings and working meetings and lots of commitment – even complete planning permission at one stage. But after six years – we are nowhere.

… and on a technical note (highlight of my week this!) I’ve added links to each post so you can easily post them on del.icio.us / digit. Thanks to Technology Wrap for the tip on how to do it easily.

Landrock Road protest

First stop major protest against the planning decision made earlier this week where Labour ignored due process and steamrollered through the granting of permission for luxury houses crammed into a backlands site in Crouch End.

I turn up at the site to find over fifty residents there to protest. The local papers are there too. I talk to the residents and following a meeting on Thursday night there has been a slight change in what they want now. Instead of the decision being looked at again in Haringey, they want to finesse the procedure and have it go to a planning appeal with one of Her Majesty’s Inspectors.

On the Cranford Way concrete factory, the Inspector over-ruled local concerns, so this isn’t a guaranteed solution – but the residents believe there’s more chance of a fair hearing on this issue with someone from outside than with Haringey Council. (The difference from the concrete factory is that the political pressure on the Council made them come out against the plans in the end). The residents are absolutely determined to take this to judicial review if necessary.

ID cards – good news

No they haven’t gone away – although the Government was forced into delays etc. But the worm is turning. As predicted – and as happened in Australia and Canada – initial high levels of public support for ID cards are falling away as people became more aware and knowledgeable about the realities of identity cards (and their huge cost – let alone database dangers).

A new poll from ICM has a majority against ID cards for the first time (and I love the Home Office spokesperson’s excuse given in the story!).

You can still help the campaign – visit www.libdems.org.uk/noidcards

CPZ success

Sometimes you win! And although it’s not over – for the time being local residents and Lib Dem councillors (and I) have won a real victory in our efforts to extend the consultation process on CPZs (controlled parking zones / residents’ parking schemes) proposed with breathtaking arrogance and flagrant disregard for all who live here by the Labour administration in Haringey.

At the big meeting on this put together by Martin Brophy (now seasoned campaigner) a few weeks ago, the responsible Labour executive member would not attend and officers of the council refused to come. But this week the Labour man – Cllr Brian Haley (who has caused a lot of controversy) – did turn up to the meeting in Crouch End.

Labour haven’t covered themselves in glory on this issue – refusing to come to previous big public meeting; keeping the CPZ proposals a secret and off the agenda of the last Muswell Hill Area Assembly; keeping them a secret from the relevant local councillors and, unbelievably, refusing to let local people bringing deputations to Full Council to even speak.

Labour never learn – the more they try and steamroller things through without proper democratic processes the more trouble they get themselves into. Anyway – Councillor Haley explained at the packed public meeting in Crouch End (at the Holy Innocents Church) that the Council’s timetable for taking a final decision on the CPZ schemes has been pushed back from September to November – to allow a new stage of ‘communication’ to take place.

Hurrah for both people power and Lib Dem campaigning! Labour’s demonstrable contempt for the people in the west of this borough has been thwarted by this twin pressure. CPZs are highly contentious at the best of times, and the only way forward is to work with the people – not against them.

Drink driving

4.00 am start and am picked up by car to get me to GMTV for a 6.12 appearance. Drink driving is on the up. Over the summer the police did a one month campaign and found that 1 in 10 drivers are driving over the limit and that about half the people the police pick up for suspicion of driving whilst having taken drugs and are therefore impaired are also nicked.

Seems to me that there is a bit of an issue going on. Breathaliser tests have decreased in the last nine years. Over the same period fatalities have increased. And not co-incidentally (in my view) traffic police have given way to cameras. Now cameras can nab you in a bus lane, in a yellow junction box and for speeding – but they can’t breathalise you. And I think that the high chance of not getting caught is beginning to make peoples’ fear of losing their license less – so they are beginning to take risks again. Combine that with the hot weather and the extension of licensing hours – and we obviously need to do some new thinking and take some new actions to damp down these figures once again.

The Government have been spending about £3 million on advertising – the shock ones that show you dreadful endings to young lives – but clearly they are not working. Shock wears off – so perhaps the ad agencies need to think how next best to challenge us on drink-driving.

Also, it may be time to look at the ‘allowance’ for drinking and bring it in line with most countries in Europe. At the moment we allow 80 milligrams of alcohol as opposed to 50 on the continent. For me it’s not so much the actuality of the level – but that it is not so easy to measure. It’s over a pint and over one glass of wine. Perhaps bringing it (and associated pub measures) in line with a level that is easier to understand and remember would help.

I would also like rather than just being delivered the new figures of one in ten drink drivers to have some drilling down into those statistics so that we know whether people are just over the limit – or whether they are now really drinking without a care.

We need to know what we are dealing with. The drink driving laws are what I regard as one of the all time successful changes in culture – from a time when no one gave a thought to how much they drank before they drove to making it socially completely unacceptable. It was done through a combination of legislation, tough enforcement, excellent penalties (losing license) and a major education campaign through TV. So if the statistics are changing – then we really need to make a move. I would have though the obvious starting place was to make sure no one feels safe about not getting caught – and accept that cameras don’t do the job on their own.

Noel Park's history

In the evening I go to the launch of a book on the history of Noel Park. You know, just sometimes you get a really unexpected evening of delight – this was one such. The author, Caroline Welch, had written this history commissioned by the Neighbourhood Management. Caroline read aloud a couple of passages from the book. The book rightly places Noel Park at the centre of Haringey’s historical landscape, highlighting the pioneering design of the social housing on the Noel Park Estate built in the late Victorian period – an artisans’ colony. A huge number of local residents from Noel Park have turned out for the evening – very impressive. The social history of our lives is wrapped up in these bricks and mortar. Architecture is social history (and one of my pet subjects actually) and it affects us and we affect it. This particular estate, named after a (very) previous MP, surname of Noel, was the outcome of philanthropic effort.

After the readings (and me), a local historian told us some Noel Park stories – and they too were fascinating. He told of a Chinese Magician who appeared at the Wood Green Empire. His speciality was to get his wife to ‘shoot’ him and then show the audience the bullet caught in his hand or sometimes spit out from where he caught it in his mouth. One day did not go so well – and he was shot dead. There were many rumours about his wife having had an affair … Lots of local stories – fascinating. And then a woman from Bruce Castle museum read out the history given to her from a local resident of ‘my first married home’. And as she talked of the furnishings, the outside loo and the net curtains – she sparked a memory for me too.

My mother had to work on Saturdays as well as during the week and she was always ‘placing’ me with one or other relative to look after me. On many Saturdays she would leave me to be looked after at a net curtaining shop on Wood Green High Road – Taylors of Wood Green – at the Turnpike Lane end. I hadn’t thought of that in years. Other members of the audience gave their memories too. The woman from Bruce Castle said that she was in charge of oral reminisces – I liked that!

Worse than having a baby

Continue to wrestle with final rewrite of edits on my chapter for forthcoming Centre Forum book Britain after Blair. It’s worse than having a baby!

Today’s emergency is the granting of planning permission to a backland site in Crouch End. Local residents, local Cllr Dave Winskill, myself and others have long campaigned against this sort of cramming development that does nothing to add to our social housing stock and everything to add to developers’ profits. However, I get a desperate email from the residents’ group to telephone them to try and get the permission certificate stopped on the basis of the proper procedures not being followed when the Planning Committee considered the application.

The residents , angry at the conduct of the meeting, want me to get the Chief Executive to delay the Permission Certificate pending an inquiry into whether these transgressions have gone as far as to open Haringey Council up to judicial review. I suspect they have and that there are grounds for judicial review. I agree with the residents. To my mind it would simply be much better to refer the decision back to Planning Committee to consider properly under proper procedures before having to go through such a lengthy and probably costly process. I make my request to Dr Donovan (Haringey CE) who promises me she is looking into it and will get back to me.

Scouts, hospital and interns

Off to the Scout Park again for photo op with local commander Simon O’Brian and Ken Ranson (of Scouting Association), two of the Safer Neighbourhood officers from Bounds Green ward and Cllr John Oakes – local councillor. We are there to meet local photographers from local papers to push hard for funding to build replacement buildings for the ones currently not ‘fit for purpose’. They are not only not fit but actually in such a state of disrepair that they can’t be used.

I am a big fan of this project. I’ve written the strongest supporting letters I know how to do to support the lottery and heritage bids. I want it for the Scouts – but I also want this amazing eight square hectares of open space in the middle of Bounds Green (that almost nobody even knows exists) to be opened up for all the local young people.

The Scouts will obviously use what they need first – but that leaves oodles of opportunities for our local youngsters. The two Safer Neighbourhood officers are running a scheme this summer for youngsters from Bounds Green between the ages of 13 and 18 to come and do outside activities. And I would like to see a mix it up program which takes kids from all the different schools – so they are not necessarily with their peer groups – and throw them together for a week of outdoors activities. The buildings and open spaces can be hired for meetings and events. There is so much that could be made of this space.

Back to the constituency office for a management meeting. I am trying to arrange a meeting with Richard Sumray – Chair of Haringey Primary Care Trust (PCT) – to push forward the Hornsey Hospital redevelopment. With the dosh now available from the government there is a possible opportunity of forcing the pace.

The hospital closed despite a massive local campaign – and the deal with the campaigners was that it would be redeveloped as a local community health facility with respite care beds etc. etc. It must be something like four or so years since we have been meeting about its future with the PCT – but nothing concrete (literally) yet.

I have decided to try and force the pace on this. The Health Trust insists it must sell off a large chunk of the land – but a) this isn’t fair and b) there is not guarantee the funds will go back into this particular site. Anyway – I spoke to Richard Sumray a couple of weeks ago and he promised me a public meeting in September. I believe Richard’s assurances that he is committed to pushing the new facility through – but I want to help him by applying as much pressure as I can. My diary organiser had phoned Richard to make the appointment but he is currently in some far flung part of the world. To be continued.

I want to know what the Council are doing about the Noel Park children’s play equipment. It made it into the press when I went over there to meet parents who are outraged that their children are facing a second summer without the promised replacement equipment. I wrote to Cllr George Meehan (Labour Leader of the Council) about it – no reply yet of course. The newspaper had a quote from the council saying they were sorry there had been a delay. But I am now going to write to Ita O’Donovan – who is the Chief Executive – as I expect she will be far more able to efficiently expedite matters than George.

Then it’s in to Parliament for the last official day of sitting – so I finish up odds and sods. I pop over with Nick Clegg (Shadow Home Secretary) for a photo op on DNA and then have dinner with my researcher and interns to thank them for their really hard work. The intern system is fantastic – hopefully for both sides. Young graduates mainly, although I have taken some school leavers and gap year students, work for expenses but get useful experience and a better of idea of what such a career might really involve – and also then get to put that they have worked for an MP on their CV. They come and go relatively quickly – but I have to say I have had some wonderful young people over the last year.

Sitting by the Thames

Too hot to think or work properly – so by the evening I drift out onto the terrace of the House of Commons for fresh air and because, quite frankly, it is absolutely beautiful. To sit with a drink gazing out on the Thames as it rolls endlessly by, and to watch the river boats and the back drop of the London Eye, is a real perk of being an MP. I know that lots of people think MPs have loads of perks etc – but in my experience this is the real perk of being an MP. As the sun begins to set, late on a summers’ evening, the lights that bath Parliament in a golden glow come on and it is just the loveliest experience to be able to sit out on a balmy (if a bit sticky) evening with all that as a backdrop.

Round-up on the week

I’ve not managed to blog much this week, so rather than go back over the details retrospectively, it seems better to simply write about the issues that spring to mind.

Very interesting meeting on Tuesday – at a numberless and nameless building with the chief of the new Serious Organised Crime Agency. This new agency is there to get a serious grip on serious crime – trafficking and drugs and major fraud and the like. It was born only a couple of months ago and so for now we could only really talk about where it was going and what it aspired to deliver. Time will tell if the very steely determination to succeed delivers.

The Prime Minister came to the Commons this week to report on the G8 meeting. It was funny reading the George / Tony miked conversation from G8 where the two big boys hadn’t realised that the microphones were on. Yo Blair! What struck me most about the conversation was Blair’s lack of concern for status in offering to go to the Middle East and talk preliminary to Condi Rice – as he states that it doesn’t matter if he comes away without a deal but that it would be bad if she did. I was actually quite impressed that his thoughts were about doing whatever it took rather than about how he looked.

The story is moving pretty fast and there seems to be a split in the Foreign Office and No 10 thinking about Hezbollah and Israel and where blame is to be apportioned. Listening to the debates in Parliament this week, the focus seems to be on condemning Israel for disproportionate action and on blaming Hezbollah for starting this round of fighting and retaliation off. The usual supporters of either side stated their usual allegiances. I really don’t think that playing the blame game helps one bit. In fact, the row in Parliament over who is more to blame mirrors almost exactly the endless row between Israel and Fatah or Hamas or Hezbollah as who is to blame.

As I have blogged before – unless George Bush and Tony Blair make the players in this tragedy come to the table and work it out – this will go on and escalate. And it won’t be the governments or the leaders of the terrorist groups or us in Parliament who pay the price – it will be the long-suffering public on all sides. They are the sacrificial lambs of the political games in the Middle East.

At the end of the week I went to an away day with some Parliamentary colleagues and Saturday was a very long surgery – and a very hot one – in the toy library at Muswell Hill.