Did Haringey Council really only mislead one set of inspectors?

This week was the special Haringey Council meeting called by the Lib Dems to debate the findings from Ed Ball’s ‘urgent investigation’ into Haringey following the death of Baby P.

It saw an astonishing outburst from the person we all saw apologise (finally) on behalf of the Labour Council – Liz Santry – Labour Member for Children’s Services as was. With the media’s attention having moved on, at this meeting I am told she lashed out blaming others. But that’s it you know – that’s the real issue in Haringey – that Labour always turn it all around and instead of really looking at what’s gone wrong, they simply rebut, deny, blame others. When will they ever learn?

What also is interesting, is that my Lib Dem colleagues on Haringey Council have called for all services to be re-inspected. This is because of the comments from Ofsted, in the form of Christine Gilbert, that they were ‘misled’ by Haringey officials when they did their inspection. If people misled one batch of inspectors, what are the chances that other inspectors carrying out other inspections were misled too?

There have been thirteen separate inspections over the last few years including the Audit Commission’s Comprehensive Performance Assessment in October 2006, the Commission for Social Care Inspection inquiry received as recently at 28th November this year and an Audit Commission report of the Council’s housing service.

There has to be now real doubt over the accuracy of these inspections – and so the call for re-inspections. Needles to say – Labour refused! As I said – when will they ever learn!

Finding the Liberal Democrats online in Haringey

Over the last year, the online presence of Haringey Liberal Democrats has steadily been growing and expanding. Five of my local colleagues now have their own sites / blogs:

Matt Davies – Fortis Green councillor
Fiyaz MughalNoel Park councillor
David SchimtzTottenham Parliamentary spokesman and Seven Sisters candidate
Neil Williams – Highgate councillor
Richard Wilson – Stroud Green councillor

Haringey Liberal Democrats are also on Facebook, including information about our forthcoming events, or – if you’re not a Facebooker – you can also instead out about our events via the main party website.

Oh, and don’t forget – I’m on Facebook, Twitter (mini-blog style updates) and Flickr (photos).

Conservative u-turn over Wards Corner

A quick update on the very popular market at Wards Corner, and the controversial development that threatens it, as I know the issue of interest to people across Haringey.

Before the Mayor elections: Boris Johnson says he’s backing local campaigners against the development.

After the Mayor elections: Boris Johnson says he won’t use his planning power to block the development nor will he use Transport for London’s ownership of the key part of the site to block it either.

Hmm … not impressed Boris! This man is for turning! Liberal Democrat Voice has more details on Wards Corner.

Islington Council wins employment case over refusal to marry same-sex couples

Islington Council has won its appeal over its dismissal of Lillian Ladele, a registrar who refused to carry out same-sex marriages. I welcome the result as it would be just as unacceptable for a registrar to refuse to marry a couple who had had premarital sex because of their religious belief. This case is no different. There is no hierarchy between strands of equality, just the principle of mutual respect and tolerance – particularly for those in public administration.

A serious topic, made fun

The Labour Government keeps on wanting to collect and keep more and more data about us. I’ve often mentioned how I think it is a waste spending large sums of money keeping tabs on the innocent rather than focusing resources on catching the guilty – but one of the other problems is that the more data that is kept about us, the more scope there is for the data to be lost and misused.

The Open Rights Group have a fun online survey which lets you find out whether any of your own personal data is likely to have been lost. You can try it here.

The Tangerine Book

The Liberal Democrat Voice team have produced a ‘book of the year’ containing a selection of articles from the last twelve months,including a trio of pieces from myself. A good present for anyone politically interested who you know!

You can buy it from Lulu or see more details on Lib Dem Voice.

The Fire Brigade Union and Brian Coleman

Well the Fire Brigade have come to my rescue for a second time. It’s not surprising that they are angry with Brian Coleman given he is supposed to set an example – not undermine all their good work on getting the message across that if you believe you are in danger get out the house:

London Fire Chief Under Fire for “Time Wasting” Jibe

LONDON, UNITED KINGDOM–(Dec. 15, 2008) – Fire Brigades Union (FBU) leaders in London have called on the chairman of the London Fire and Emergency Planning Authority (LFEPA) to consider his position, after he labelled as “dizzy” and an “airhead” a woman MP who dialled 999 when sparks began to fly from her boiler.

Conservative councillor Brian Coleman’s remarks were branded “sexist” by Lynne Featherstone, Liberal Democrat member of parliament for Hornsey and Wood Green, who said she intends to protest to the London Fire Brigade commissioner, Ron Dobson.

Ms Featherstone was in her house late at night with her two daughters when the boiler began to violently shake and emit sparks. Fearing an explosion, she evacuated the house and called the fire brigade.

The incident came to light after Ms Featherstone wrote an entry on her website blog, in which she praised firefighters for their actions.

However, Cllr Coleman accused Ms Featherstone of wasting brigade time and said she should have called a plumber instead. “She has shown herself to be completely dizzy. Airheads and airlocks are obviously not unrelated. She can’t tell the difference between an airlock and a major catastrophe,” Coleman told the Daily Mail.

Cllr Coleman also suggested Ms Featherstone send a cheque to the London Fire Brigade in recompense for the incident, in what would be a break with centuries of tradition of the fire service being free at the point of use for members of the public.

However, the FBU has slammed Cllr Coleman for engaging in cheap political point-scoring and dispensing erroneous advice. The union warned that his comments may discourage other members of the public from dialling 999 for fear of being accused of wasting brigade time. A spokesman for the London Fire Brigade also contradicted Cllr Coleman’s comments by making clear that Ms Featherstone acted correctly.

The FBU’s regional secretary for London, Joe MacVeigh, said, “To put narrow political considerations before public safety, as Councillor Coleman has done, is unpardonable. Any firefighter will tell you that Ms Featherstone did absolutely the right thing, and, by publicly condemning her, Councillor Coleman has raised question marks about his own suitability for office.

“You cannot have the head of London’s fire authority blundering around instructing people not to call the fire brigade when they have perfectly good reason to. The huge amount of time that our members spend on educating the public about fire safety can turn to dust with crass remarks like these.”

Mr MacVeigh also condemned the sexist nature of Councillor Coleman’s comments. “As the head of LFEPA, Councillor Coleman has a duty to promote sound equalities and diversity policies. He even recently claimed that the London Fire Brigade was ‘taking the lead on equality issues’. If an ordinary firefighter had said such things to a female colleague, he would almost certainly have been facing disciplinary action. It seems to me that Councillor Coleman needs to decide whether he wants to be a serious politician or whether he wants to continue as City Hall’s resident joker.”

Brian Coleman and the Fire Brigade

I posted a ‘thank you’ to Hornsey firefighters for coming out on a 999 call to my house a little while back – with a very brief description of what had happened. At the end of last week, Brian Coleman, Conservative Chair of the London Fire Authority was all over the media attacking me for doing so. Although the Fire Brigade says I did the right thing to call them out – and would only have sent firefighters if they thought it necessary – he says I should pay; that it was comparable with calling them out for a pet stuck in a tree; he has called me ‘dizzy’, ‘an airhead’; ‘an utter disgrace’ and so on.

What I would say about this – and all the comment that has ensued in the media (Mr Coleman actually sent out press releases to attack me) – is that I and my two daughters were terrified and that is the point. The corner of the house was shaking. The noise was extreme. In those moments – it is the clear message of the Fire Brigade that steered me through. And their advice is if you think you are in danger get out of the house and call the Fire Brigade – which is exactly what I did.

Thank goodness there was no explosion – but it was serious and when the engineer came the next day he said that the jammed motor had been sparking and as well as causing the shaking and the noise and it could have ignited. The Hornsey firefighters, when they came, checked everything and made sure it was safe.

So as I simply followed the official advice of the Fire Brigade – I have been astonished that someone in Brian Coleman’s position (i.e. chair of the London Fire Authority) would undermine that message from the Fire Service – just to have a pop at someone in a different political party.

A London Fire Brigade spokeswoman said: “If it’s obvious that there has been an ongoing problem with the boiler, then you can call a plumber. But if your boiler suddenly starts making strange noises in the middle of the night, call the fire brigade.” Mine was the latter situation – and so both the Fire Commission and the firefighters on the night said I did the right thing.

As you may have seen – there’s been a fair few comments on this blog, so I just wanted to highlight a couple:

Hi as a serving firefighter, I can honestly say you did exactly the right thing in calling out your local fire service. The fire service has a responsibility to serve the community in all ways. Community safety is at the forefront of what we do, we would much rather see early action being taken than having to deal with the aftermath of a catastrophic failure. Your boiler could have potentially been life threatening either through a defective flue or indeed an explosion. May I suggest both a carbon monoxide detector and a smoke detector be fitted if you do not have either. Ready to serve and protect.

and

i am a fire fighter at hornsey fire station and although i am not a Libdem supporter and i was not on duty when you called us, i would like you to know that you did the correct thing. our job is to serve and protect the community and if you felt you and your family were in danger then you have a duty of care to call us asap. brian colemans comment shows how little he knows about the role of the LFB and his statement that your were dizzy is quite frankly extremely sexist and condescending, but what else can we expect from one of the mayors hand picked cronies.

I will be writing to the Commissioner of the London Fire Service – on two counts. Firstly, on the issue of how he will deal with a Chair of the Authority who is happy to send out a message which is completely contradictory to the ethic and central message of the Fire Service. Secondly, in a service in which there is a strong shift to move away from any discrimination or sexism – to ask what action he will take over having a Chair who thinks it is OK to denigrate women in the way Brian Coleman did. Those who know Mr Coleman say this is typical. But I don’t think you can hold such a responsible position and then say – well it’s politics, so it doesn’t count.

The Westminster Hour: 10pm, Radio 4

Appearing on Radio 4's The Westminster Hour with Carolyn QuinnI’m back on The Westminster Hour tonight (Sunday): Radio 4, 10pm.

If you miss the show you’ll be able to listen again on their website.

If you want to get advanced notice of my media appearances like this one, you can use the media events service at Flock Together. You’ve got three choices:

  1. Using this feed: http://feeds.feedburner.com/LiberalDemocratsMediaAppearances, or
  2. By email: register at FlockTogether and pick “Media appearances” as one of the categories of events you want to be emailed about. (If you are an existing Flock Together user you can also change your preferences – login and then click “Edit your preferences” in the left-hand menu; you need to tick “Media Appearances” under “Email options”), or
  3. On the web: take a look at the dedicated Flock Together page.

Highgate Choral Society

Last night it was off to St Michael’s Church in Highgate Village for the Christmas anthems and audience carols by the Highgate Choral Society, of which I am a patron. As ever – mulled wine and mince pies and beautiful singing by the Chorus and of course the audience. And there were some lovely organ solos as well.

Particularly sweet, I thought, was that the first chorus of Away in the Manger, Ronald Corp who is the conductor (amongst many other competing titles in his CV) asked that only the children sing. And the very faint but very sweet little voices were just delightful.

The whole evening was as enjoyable as ever – and I am very much looking forward to April, when the Chorus has its 130th anniversary celebratory concert at the Barbican Centre on Thursday 2nd April. If you are interested in joining, supporting or attending – their website is www.hcschoir.com.