Local services for local people

Interesting meeting with the committee running the St James Pre-School playgroup. Squeezed by Government and local council so that they can barely function. Too complicated to go into here – but long and short is that funding follows the child. The funding for those on Income Support falls short of the real cost of paying for the staff . So in order to fund the differential gap – the other parents have to make voluntary contributions – and most are willing. This school has only four on income support – so the other parents fund their own extra costs and sub these four – but in playgroups where there are overwhelmingly kids from families on income support – the whole thing is getting completely untenable. I suspect that is the Government’s intention – to squeeze until they are all forced to close or become private nurseries. They can then force everyone into schools or childrens’ centres and never mind the loss of the wonderful local groups in the community. I really hate this government at times.

Then I dash to see a man who is unhappy about parking. I know – there are lots out there. He lives on a main road and bus route and is cross that Haringey Council have brought in pavement parking outside his house to stop buses getting stuck in Middle Lane and speed their progress. He doesn’t like the noise the buses make now they go faster and believes that the Council have lied on the their consultation document where they say that the pavement parking and double yellows on corners will improve things for residents. Well – I’m not the one to defend the Labour Council and they do lie. However, speeding up buses is necessary so that more people use public transport. But as a car and motorcycle enthusiast – he was not truly sold the argument that we need more and better public transport and the logic was lost on him. However, he is right about needing signs for school children, and better design of the pavement parking and am happy to take that up.

Then on to the TreeHouse Trust. This is an organisation formed out of desperation by parents of autistic children because the state offered care was hard to get and not necessarily the best. So some years on, TreeHouse have developed into a really fantastic group who have now built (temporarily in temporary buildings) a school for autistic children in Muswell Hill. It is fabulous. The care, the education, the pastoral care, the staff, the atmosphere, the ambition for the children was absolutely fantastic.

My fury is reserved for the trouble they have getting local councils (and they take from across the whole of London) to fund a child to be placed there. Yes – they are a bit more expensive than council places in special schools – but the care is so much geared to that very special condition.

Currently, I have been trying to get Haringey to fund a local child place there – but they refuse. The family are going to go into debt to send their son there.

Flew in and out of my youngest daughter’s school for a meeting about forthcoming art trip to Berlin and then met a delegation on behalf of Greek Cypriots.

And of course – today was Tony’s revenge. He always caps Brown. On the Monday you think Brown has got it in the bag – and damn it – by Tuesday lunchtime Tony has the conference eating out of his hand again. Gordon must be spitting as I reckon that was quite a clear indication that Blair is not hanging up his hat in the near future…

Who is Gordon Brown?

Have a meeting at the pub (my constituency office is in the rooms upstairs of the Three Compasses pub). Sometimes I hold small one-to-one meetings downstairs in the pub itself – particularly in the morning when it is quiet before the lunchtime rush. The atmosphere is fabulously relaxing and I buy coffee or whatever and we sit on comfy sofas or chairs – and you get a lot more out of people in that way.

This meeting was particularly useful as the previous Monday, Mark Oaten (who is LibDem Shadow Home Secretary) had added prisons to my brief and I was about to visit Holloway Prison this coming Wednesday. So Lucy Russell, Director of Smart Justice, had come to lobby me about women prisoner’ issues – which was very fortuitous.

What struck me was how desperately disproportionate the consequences of prison often are for women and their family. To elucidate – punishment has an important role to play in society not just to keep the public safe but to be the price paid for unlawful behaviour. However, the majority of women serve less than six months. Going to prison more often than not means children in care or at the very least disturbed from their home; quite often loss of home and so on. So when you look at the total impact of the sentence, it’s much more than just the sentence itself. That needs to be remembered and dealt with.

Muswell Hill and Highgate Area Assembly in the evening. Not particularly well-attended and I swear I know virtually everyone there. The problem remains how to get ‘real’ people in greater numbers – at times other than when there is a CPZ proposal on the agenda when there is no shortage of attendees.

Tonight it would have been very useful if the council had made more effort to publicize the meeting as it was the opportunity for local residents to choose projects to fund from the local assembly’s budget. All the nominations were up on the wall and each resident in attendance got six green dot stickers to stick up. But lots of really great small projects nominated by various locals – and not really enough of the local residents there to indicate their preferences from which the local councillors then decide.

The main topics however were the future of Park Road Pool and trees. Good news-ish on the pool – it does have a future. Over the next few years lots of improvements promised and the community will still be able to use a room for local activities. Sounds good, but this being Haringey – we’ll see. They had done no work whatsoever on public transport for the venue – simply indicated that they were trying to expand the car park. That is fine (to a degree) but you do need to be able to get there by bus and there is only a very limited service since they removed the W2. Also – they had had no talks with Hornsey Central Hospital – who are just along the road and following my questions on this, work is going ahead on the site in the New Year.

The other main event of the day was watching Gordon Brown deliver his succession speech at the Labour conference. I was under-whelmed. I don’t think it is going to happen soon and I don’t think it is going to do Labour much good in the long run if he does succeed. He doesn’t know which way to play it – New or Old! In reality he has been relentlessly New Labour – so no idea why the ‘left’ think he may be their saviour. Who signed the cheques for the Iraq war? Who forced through part-privatisation of the Tube? Who insisted on top-up fees for students? And on and on.

Therein is the problem – who really is Gordon Brown?

Visiting Camden

Queen Mum stuff! That’s what I call it when I am invited to Lib Dem local party social events or meetings to gee up the troops. Troop geeing up is variable – dependent on nature of local party. This was for Camden Liberal Democrats and held in Belsize Ward. Hosted by Alexis and Laura – who really pulled out all the stops for fantastic, proper, real cooked food! I am there to talk to people and enthuse them for giving their all – be that money, time or blood. And if the food is good – the giving is greater.

I work my way around the attendees and also make a speech. Of course, the Hornsey & Wood Green story (or how I overturned a Labour lead over me in ’97 of 26,000 into a 2,400 majority in 2005) is stirring stories for girls and boys in Labour seats. I do my stuff – and if I were a betting man I would put some money on Lib Dems gaining quite a few council seats next May. And in the General – well watch out Glenda!

Liberal Democrat conference, Blackpool

My bags are packed and I hi-tailed it out of town on Saturday morning from Euston. On the train, I sit down and the woman across the aisle from me immediately asks me if I am Lynne Featherstone. I cannot tell a lie! Actually, she turned out to be a constituent living in Creighton Avenue on her way to Glasgow to visit her Mum and we had a few enjoyable hours putting the world to rights; if only we were in charge!

Blackpool may well be a wonderful place for stag nights and hen parties for the young, drunk and noisy, but – sober and middle-aged, truly sorry and no offence meant, it would not be my first choice. Every time I enter the Winter Gardens – which is the conference centre – I try and imagine what nightmares were haunting the author of the design brief. Must have been truly evil!

The Conference Hotel is adequate – but is nowhere near the Winter Gardens and so the delegates are consigned to spending a good part of each day travelling between the two from main hall debates at the Winter Garden to all the fringe meetings at the main hotel and others. In fact, the local authority provided a free shuttle bus – but hardly anyone was told.

But to the business. My guess is – as always – that the media will focus on whether Lib Dems are going to the right or the left and whether Charlie boy’s leadership will be challenged. I turn out to be right on both counts. I do one fringe meeting on the right/left kafuffle. The title of the event is ‘Can the Liberal Democrats be part of a Progressive Consensus’? This is hosted by the Independent Newspaper and chaired by Steve Richards who does the early Sunday morning politics show on GMTV. (You can read my speech on my website).

I have a go a Gordon Brown – basically. Don’t believe he is capable of a consensus – progressive or otherwise. Or more accurately, Brown’s progressive consensus is just that – OK so long as you agree with him. Anyway – as everyone knows – I think Brown is a coward who keeps his head down below the parapet when the going gets tough, votes a straight New Labour ticket, is the author of the astronomically expensive and appalling part-privatisation of the tube and who broods in the shadows whilst waiting for Tony’s tide to go out.

But what the media really, really want – is for the Liberal Democrats to tear themselves apart on the basis that those of us who fight or represent old Tory seats will want to shift to the right and those of us who fight or represent old Labour seats (like me) will want to be on the centre-left of the political spectrum.

Clearly a disappointing night then as all four of us speakers – Simon Hughes, David Laws, Vince Cable and myself – in one way or another all argue that it isn’t a matter of right left – it’s about Liberal values. Especially when the Labour government is knee-jerking poorly thought out legislation into being and striking at the principles of justice and freedom that make our country what it is.

The other great debate going on is about multiculturalism and what it means to be British, particularly after 7/7.

Trevor Phillips, Chair of the Commission for Racial Equality, has thrown down the gauntlet with a nifty little sound bite: ‘we are sleepwalking our way into segregation’. His thesis being that we live in our cultural enclaves and mix less and less. Statement of the bleeding obvious I should say – although it strikes me lots of politicos are fundamentally in denial whilst a Sky TV poll clearly puts over 80% + of real people in line with that thesis.

I get two bites at this issue. I speak at a fringe meeting and then there is also a debate in the main hall.

For the debate, conference has introduced a new format where representatives send in their preferred topic for a discussion on an urgent issue. There is no motion or vote – but people’s views are taken back and with further work and consultation a motion will then be brought back to the next conference for decision. It’s my job to summate the debate.

I have my own views too- and whilst I do think we are becoming a segregated society, I don’t think the 7/7 bombers were making a statement about poverty or alienation when they blew us up or that solving the issues of poverty and alienation in our ethnic communities will have anything but a tiny effect on terrorism in ours or any Western country. Terrorists don’t generally come from the poorest or most alienated.

However, history has given us a bit of a lesson about where extremists go to find fodder for their causes. So whilst tackling poverty and alienation won’t directly stop terrorism, it will help make it harder for terrorists to recruit support in future.

I also chair two of the keynote speeches in the main hall. The second one is for my Home Affairs team leader – Mark Oaten – our Shadow Home Secretary. So with only a sentence or two to say I introduce him as the ‘toughest Liberal I know’ – a phrase picked up by the media sketch writers for the Telegraph and the Guardian! Mark had said a couple of days earlier that he would kill me if I introduced him thus – but I did it purposefully as I believe that ‘tough liberalism’ is the way forward – particularly in terms of law and order.

Mark gave a bravura speech.

I (and you will thank me for this) am not going to go through every fringe I spoke at – but I was allowed to pontificate on a much wider range of subjects than ever before. In my previous incarnation I was kept pretty much to my policing and transport portfolios. This time – outside of my usual training sessions for the party on ‘How we Won Hornsey & Wood Green’ and ‘Grow your Own Target Seat’, I covered Lords – the Last Bastion of Freedom?, What Difference would Electoral Reform make to Women? (not a great deal in my view); The Future of our Towns; Making the Breakthrough (or how to get our arses into gear in the 100+ seats we are second to Labour in for next time); Blogging and so on.

New experience for me (it is always great to do something you have never done before) was something called GNS. I had to go and do the radio responses on what Mark Oaten had said about breaking the consensus around Labour’s proposed new terrorist legislation. Whilst we support three of the proposals – an offence of training for terrorism, incitement to terrorism and acts preparatory to terrorism – we can’t support an offence ‘glorification of terrorism’ or the ‘three months detention without trial’. Briefly – the ‘glorification’ one is just too wide a definition. It would turn into a feast for lawyers all interpreting (as is their job) but with such a wide spectrum that it would be very hard for such legislation to be effective – and you don’t want the real terrorist dodging around the new legislation because it is poor and they have a good lawyer.

The other – three months detention – strikes at the very heart of our principles of justice – and is another form of internment. Moreover, having seen how stop and search works in practice when I was on the Metropolitan Police Authority – it would be just too easy for profiling to lead to autom
atic three month detention on suspicion – and suspicion as we tragically know from the Met shooting an innocent Br
azilian isn’t enough. And if after 14 days they need more evidence and more time, there are other ways. They currently put people under surveillance and the numbers are not such that that would be too difficult or expensive. In fact it might very well concentrate the police mind on intelligence-based evidence rather than suspicion. Three months internment would make them casual in their rigour.

Anyway – none of this was the point of my tale. The tale was about the GNS process. I was to speak for eight minutes to each BBC radio station around the country – live! So with headphones on in a tiny studio and with an electronics box – one after another station around the country dialled me up and did the interview. It was pretty tough going. I was just brilliant by about the fifth one – when I had got all my best lines in place – but definitely going off the boil with over-confidence by the ninth! But – as I say – had never even heard of this type of interview before.

And so – the rest was a late dinner with friends and pretty early to bed – and yes – it really was all work!

Housing in Haringey

From 9am until 1pm I do my surgery at Wood Green Library. I could truly weep over the housing situation in Haringey. 17,000 people on the housing register and only 349 homes built last year by housing associations.

There is more building going on now and proposals in – particularly in the Wood Green area. But despite Livingstone’s promises, the majority are poorly designed and use the crappiest materials. Lowest common denominator stuff. I am sick of Ken’s words not being backed by real delivery on the ground. I support increased good housing proposals around transport hubs – but so often it’s a matter of where is the quality, where is the infrastructure? Nowhere in sight! Unbearable – lives are blighted for decades by this crap. And far too many applications which are totally unsuitable for the areas they are proposed in.

Spend rest of day once again desperately churning out speeches – finish about 9pm. The on Saturday it’s off to Blackpool. Not sure I’ll have access to blog through conference – but if not, will catch up at end of the week.

Speech writing

Off to Parliament to catch up with my office working there. Also interviews with BBC Online and Evening Standard. Rush back around 3pm to continue writing blasted speeches. Sometimes it’s easy – sometimes it isn’t. My “Progressive Consensus” keeps changing, and changing!

Getting ready for party conference

Off to constituency HQ for an interview with Radio 4 who are doing profiles on six new MPs – two from each party. Don’t know how much longer I will be a ‘new’ girl – but it obviously has its advantages!

It’s a very long interview but all very enjoyable. Then back up to office to do some work. Now set up, with computers networked and staff in place – at last feel that normal service has been resumed. It is quite a change from having done everything virtually myself for the last eight years to having a team of staff – but very necessary given all the extra work being an MP involves. They are doing a great job – but inevitably setting up two offices (constituency and in Parliament) takes some time.

My mother gave me three pieces of advice before she died: firstly from her experience running her own successful business – the customer is always right. It’s an old-fashioned concept but one I personally think still holds good. Secondly, the person in charge must know about any complaint against the company. If you don’t know what is going wrong you cannot correct it! The other piece of advice – well that was personal.

Lib Dem conference in Blackpool is zooming towards me – and finally getting hold of my diary I discover that I have around twelve speeches to write before I leave on Saturday – a smattering as examples are “Can the Liberal Democrats be part of a progressive consensus?”, “What is Britishness?” (the in debate of the moment), “Is the Lords the last bastion of freedom?”, and lots, lots more.

Topped by the party’s Head of Policy phoning me to ask if I would summate on an urgent debate in the main hall: “What future for multiculturalism post 7/7?” I am also chairing two sessions in the main hall – Graham Watson MEP and Mark Oaten MP. The fun never stops! So in between other engagements this week I am desperately trying to write these speeches.

In the evening I go to a big public meeting about the proposals for a concrete factory right in the middle of a residential area. About 2-300 people in attendance and an array of Labour (council leader, his deputy, Tottenham MP and a couple of local councillors).

Myself and Laura Edge (Lib Dem councillor for Stroud Green) and several other Lib Dems also there. Labour have called this meeting at short notice, and not told anyone much it was happening. So I had to try and let people know about it at short notice. Laura and her colleagues were great at helping me let as many people know as possible. Plus the glories of email for sending information round quickly! (If you live in my constituency and would like to get similar emails in future, just let email with your name and postcode – lynne@lynnefeatherstone.org).

Am much amused that Labour have suddenly taken enough fright – possible because they fear losing the local elections next May and have realised that we Lib Dems have been campaigning and working with local residents and their campaign group, Green N8, for the last year.

Consultants representing London Concrete (who want to build the plant) are there – but no show from any of the directors etc from the actual company. Bad form! They give pretty feeble answers to the many, many questions raised by the audience who are worried sick about the level of noise, pollution and congestion that will be caused by this application.

We (elected reps) from both east and west of the borough unite to fight off the application. Political pressure is a wonderful thing – but lets hope it is reflected in the rejection of the new proposals going to Planning Committee on October 10.

I exhort everyone to write individually to the planning department and to the Planning Inspector (there is a coterminous appeal on a first application that was rejected). I also suggest they write to Ken Livingston who is misguidedly supporting the application because of the factory being able to bring aggregates in by rail. Firstly – there are no guarantees of capacity on the line. Secondly – the couple of trains a day benefit does not stand against the disadvantage caused by the articulated lorry movements etc.

And, we're off again!

And we’re off! Once more into the breach. Today’s first visit – to my newly up and running constituency office; for now above the Three Compasses Pub in Hornsey High Street. And at last phones and computer systems are up and networked and running. It has been rather a challenge to set up two offices and try and make sure nothing and no-one slips through the net whilst in transit from doing everything under my own roof at home as it has been for the last nine years.

Later, I’m at the opening of a little five-house development by an Irish Housing Association, Innisfree, and then am guest speaker at their AGM. Funnily enough really, as I campaign so often against infills and backland development (squeezing new housing on small patches of open land in already built-up areas)! But this is a rare example of a site for which – although there was a campaign against this development – it is hard to argue against, as it is small houses with gardens for social housing. Two of the houses had disabled access – and as about half the cases that walk through my surgery door are to do with housing shortages – this is a development I can live with.

Campaigning against backland development is one of my passions, as I believe the damage being done in the long term to quality of life is severe. However, those are always against greedy developers trying to maximise profit from inappropriate locations at local peoples’ expense. Regrettably, the planning system is blind to those sorts of sentiments. We are absolutely desperate for social housing in Haringey. There are about 17,000 residents in Haringey on the housing register yet only about 349 homes were built last year by Housing Associations.

Anyway – in the evening I was the guest speaker at their AGM and I was greatly impressed by the warmth and atmosphere, and indeed success, of this Housing Association. I deal with many Housing Associations and – believe me – they are variable in their standards. Sometimes I feel that the lousy ones put residents in a position where they feel powerless. The council can always turn round and say ‘not me gov’ in response to complaints, so there is then all too often no pressure that can be effectively applied to the Housing Association to improve its act except in the rare cases of an actual breach of legal terms.

Visiting a local mosque

Last visit of the day is to the Wightman Road Mosque. Excellent conversation with the President, Secretary and Treasurer of the Trust which runs the mosque.

We sit in a meeting room upstairs and range our discussion across the obvious issues of the day. We all agree that more engagement is necessary to offset the suspicion that has fallen on the Muslim population so unfairly in almost all cases. Clearly Iraq looms large in the causes of bombing coming to our shores. I think Tony Blair’s early denial that the war was anything to do with the bombings was just the most stupid thing he could say. Not a direct and solitary cause of course – but to say it played no part – ridiculous.

However, we are all solidly agreed that bombing and violence have no place in a democratic society. From which we move to the fact that so many of the community did not vote and do not believe in engaging in the democratic process. I suggest that along with coming to the mosque so that young people have the opportunity to question and talk with me (an MP) directly, that in addition if there are groups of youngsters (or anyone) who would like to come to tour Parliament and meet myself and a few other MPs I would be happy to arrange such a visit. I think engagement in the political life and process of the country is vital.

This is a well run mosque who have banned some of the organisations the media give so much time to. They are worried that T Blair’s proposals will drive such groups underground and that no one will know any longer where danger lurks – because even the Muslim community won’t know.

They are upset at the deportations and we talk about the pros and cons. I suggest that if they found the need to ban groups from the Mosque – then you could see the potential need to ban certain groups and to deport certain people. I think the difference is that the offending groups were given the opportunity under warning to stop what they were doing or they would be banned. Perhaps that would be a better proposal then just banning and creating an underground and martyrs.

These are difficult and challenging times. I generally find being myself and sticking to my guns steers me well through most situations regardless of what those challenges are. It is never any use saying something you don’t believe and agreeing with something just because you know that someone wants you to. You just have to say what you really think whilst being sensitive to how other people feel from their perspectives. It’s not rocket science.

And then I trudge homewards. I am actually still working until next Tuesday – but in terms of blogging – I will be taking my usual mid-year break and will be back around mid-September. So – see you then – in what will undoubtedly be a lively period in British politics.

Housing problems in Haringey

Surgery all morning. (One blog reader asked if all the surgeries I do mean I’m a doctor. In case you don’t know – I’m not at the operating table, but rather it’s an advice session people come to, so they can talk to me in person, face-to-face about an issue they need help with).

I cannot count the number of people who come with housing misery stories – too many people in one room, appalling conditions, etc – and the points they need to qualify for re-housing always seem to change just as they are about to achieve the required number.

Today was no exception. One couple had been in private accommodation which got flooded so they had to move out to stay with the woman’s mother. Two children later and sleeping all four in one room, they got within six points of being re-housed – when the goalposts moved. Years later they are still there

I asked if they had thought of renting in the private market – but they said it was too expensive and their daughter was at a local school and the mother helped with childcare – all very valid of course.

However, as I said to them, if the Council were to tell you that realistically you are unlikely to get re-housed for another ten years – might you then decide to move further out where it is cheaper, even though you have to change your daughter’s school and lose the easy and convenient help being with your mother brings? Yes – they said. And therein lies a huge problem – people are not able to make informed decisions about what to do as they live in a world of ever-shifting, non-delivered promises.

Of course, some do eventually get there – which leads me to another conclusion about the system we have: the system itself creates problems. For example – you get more points if you have extra criteria that count. One that whisks across my surgery desk regularly is a doctor’s letter confirming depression or asthma or whatever – and the more illnesses and the more severe the more points! Now of course this is right in a way because need increases – but as with all the systems it seems to encourage people to be less able and discourages people from battling for better health.

Conversely, it leaves people who manage through adversity worse off. I saw one woman, a single mother bringing up four children in inappropriate accommodation for 18 years, but with no qualifying ‘extras’ and doing a great job keeping all their heads above water. She will probably never get re-housed because she is determined to cope with it all regardless. Perverse incentives all over the place!