Fortismere School update

So – Fortismere – our local educational star in the Haringey firmament – has decided to move out of our close-knit school community and change to foundation status. That will now go out to statutory consultation for a very, very short four weeks – so if you want to have your say have it quickly. My understanding of the ‘informal’ consultation results were that there were 70% against this move albeit from a rather small response rate of 6%. I stand to be corrected on those figures as they are from reportage and memory.

The community is upset and divided on this issue. My personal position – as I am asked continually – is that the school should simply stay a good local community school. My role, however, is to try and make sure that the parents and community have a fair say in the future of this excellent school.

This proposal and decision has set parent against parent and has been extremely distressing for many of those involved. Parents of statemented children have come to me worried that the school will reduce their number. Parents in favour of the proposals have contacted me to say that they have been intimidated by those against the proposals – to the point of feeling unable to even voice their views in public.

I receive so many different stories about promises unmet on mode and extent of consultation, on one group thinking x and another wanting y. That is why I very early on wrote to the Head and Governors to hold an all-parent ballot. This was refused. But how else can we really know what parents want as a body? And the teachers? And the pupils? And the local community? We are all inter-linked.

The LEA are not blameless in all of this either. Nor the Government. One of the factors that prompted the school to take this path – or at least seems to have confirmed it in the direction it is bent on taking – is the Labour Government and the Labour LEA between them refusing to grant enough capital funding to deal with a degrading sixth form building and Portacabins that have been there for decades.

I went with the Head and school governors to Ministers before all this started because the Building Schools for the Future fund provided by the Government for new buildings and apportioned to Haringey schools by Haringey Labour LEA had put Fortismere at the very bottom – with clearly no potential to solve their building problems for the next ten years. The Government wouldn’t consider giving any more money – saying it was up to the LEA to distribute that fund. The LEA said they couldn’t distribute it any other way as the Government controlled the funding allocation by criteria which were weighted less to do with the need for new building and much more to do with deprivation factors. Inevitably the poorer areas received more funding – even if buildings in less deprived areas were more in need of work. That means that a high-achieving school like Fortismere with a relatively comfortable catchment wasn’t even in the game despite having crumbling building fabric.

So – I feel that the combination of LEA and Government has given the school the ideal excuse to go to parents and explain that if they didn’t take this path etc etc they would not be able to have the desperately needed new buildings. Only control over their own assets – which comes with this change – would supply the funding they need. Of course – a whole raft of other concerns are involved from possible selection to reducing the numbers of statemented children. Denials of this from the school. Counter denials from the campaigners who want to keep the school comprehensive.

I don’t know if the moves to call for a judicial review on the grounds of flawed consultation will come to anything – there may well be some mechanism and maybe some mileage. I still believe that there should be a ballot – not just to canvas true opinion but also so that once the decision is finally made it could have been fair and seen to be fair and therefore all parties could move forward together and put this miserable experience where no one trusts anyone behind them.

I offered to broker a meeting between Fortismere and the LEA but the LEA could not find a suitable time or date for such a meeting. A great shame – but seemingly the process rolls on, and now – in the last phase – there is just this statutory consultation and that will finish mid July.

Why should you have to ask the police eight times to help?

Last stop of the day is the Kurdish Community Centre in Portland Gardens N4. It is the start of the three-day festival celebrating women. Tonight I am on a panel of four women – two of the others of whom are famous Kurdish human rights campaigners and we are speaking on: ‘Kurdish Women – Fighting for Freedom Against Violence’.

The struggle of Kurdish women is astonishing – the violence against them (and of course other women too – sadly it’s universal) is too terrible.

But so is the reaction of our police – sadly. You may have read recently of Banaz Mahmod – the so-called Honour Killing. Domestic violence is what that was – men dominating women’s lives as if we are still their chattels. Makes me sick. But Banaz went to the police six times – and they took virtually no notice.

A woman in the audience this evening raised her hand to say that it happened to her too. She went to the police eight times – and they did not help her. I said to the women there – that if they find themselves in that position and the police do nothing after even the first time they go for help – then they must go to their Member of Parliament. For if I have a Kurdish (or any) women come to me who says she is in danger and the police are doing nothing I will raise it in Parliament and in the media and anywhere to get attention. The police have come a long way on rape and domestic violence – but clearly not nearly far enough.

National Childminding Week

Hornsey childminder visitAfter the Winkfield visit, it was on to Karyn Parker’s house in Hornsey. Karyn is a registered childminder in Haringey – and exemplar.

Three parents are there to meet with me (some who used Karyn for years past and present) and their children. Jo, Vera and Tracy are mums who without the peace of mind of knowing that their offspring are safe and sound – and more to the point – loved, would not be able to go to work as they do. I know that one only too well myself. It was clear that the children of mixed ages had a lovely environment, were stimulated and socialised and safe. As Jo said to me – you want a childminder who as much as possible does what you would do. And that’s the point.

Karyn is now mentoring other child minders. This is the real nuts and bolts of equality for me. Without good affordable childcare – women cannot get back to work. So I was really delighted to meet Karyn (who is absolutely wonderful) – and delighted to do so in support of National Childminding Week – which is why I was there!

Helping deaf and hard of hearing people get jobs

Following Renate Campbell cuts the cake to open the Deaf Job Clubmy morning advice surgery at Wood Green Library, I went to the launch of the Renate Campbell Trust Deaf Job Club at the Winkfield Resource Centre. In short – this will be a facility, for the deaf and hard of hearing, where staff will be there to help them into work. This might comprise support in putting a CV together or learning skills – as well as educating employers and providing training awareness for staff.

Renate is the daughter of former Labour councillor Mary Neuner, who in middle life literally woke up one morning deaf. Mary worked tirelessly to improve things for the deaf and this launch today is on the back of her efforts. Mary was a real driving force and it is terribly sad that she, herself, died only recently. At least she knew that this was going to happen.

It is one of those things in life, you know. Most people don’t even know someone who is deaf. Most people don’t know someone in a wheelchair. And what people don’t have in their own lives appears as strange and alien. And I am sure that employers or would be employers think that deaf people won’t be able to do the job or it will cost them to have one working for them. And yet – if it is your mother or brother who is deaf, or blind or in a wheelchair or whatever – then they are just people – same as you or me. I have this total belief in a better world where the differences are as nothing compared to what we have in common. And that cuts across not just disability – but culture, race and religion too!

Councillors slam long delays in repairing burst water mains at local school

Councillor Wayne Hoban, Liberal Democrat member for Alexandra ward, has criticised local agencies for allowing a burst water main at a local school to remain broken. The water main burst at Alexandra Park School on 12th June 2007 but was allowed to continue flowing for several days whilst Thames Water, the Fire Service and Jarvis, the PFI maintenance contractor to the school, argued over whose responsibility it was to undertake the repair. It has been revealed that the leak originated when a water main was broken when the Fire Brigade drove over the kerb when they went down the side road to tackle the fire at Muswell Hill Golf Club.

Cllr Wayne Hoban (Alexandra Ward) comments:

“Surely the primary responsibility was to repair the leak immediately to ensure that disruption to the school was kept to a minimum and also to prevent thousands of gallons of precious water from being wasted.I am extremely concerned that essential public agencies could not see the logic of undertaking this repair immediately and sorting out ultimate responsibility later.”

Cllr Gail Engert, Lib Dem Spokesperson for Children and Young People adds:

“This situation illustrates the complications that arise when a school is locked into a maintenance contract with a Private Finance Initiative (PFI) provider and is unable to deal with the problem directly. This is very unsatisfactory, given the huge inconvenience caused.”

Liberal Democrats slam Haringey Council project management

Haringey Liberal Democrats have yet again criticised and expressed their concern at Haringey Council’s poorly controlled and ineffective project management.

Information revealed at the Haringey Council Cabinet meeting of top Labour councillors on 19th June 2007 included a report which included no summary budget information for almost one in five of the projects.

More significantly, the report shows over half the projects are running late or forecast to complete after their “original end date” and a further one in five show no summary date information on which to see whether they are late or not.

Haringey Liberal Democrat councillors believe this shows Labour’s lack of attention to detail and poor track record of running large projects that have resulted in huge waste of Haringey taxpayers’ money through disasters such as the Tech Refresh fiasco.

Projects currently running behind schedule include the procurement project tasked to make savings of £2 million. The original completion date was April 2007 but now forecast to finish in April 2009 – 2 years late.

Another example is project to deliver The Single Status Pay Review settlement. This was cited as “one of the key risk issues” in this year’s Haringey Council Budget process and an issue which may produce “significant costs”. The project to reach a settlement now shows a forecast completion of Jan 2009 from an original completion date of March 2007 – 22 months late.

Cllr Robert Gorrie, Lib Dem Finance Spokesperson comments:

“Successful project management is about two key things – delivering on time and on budget. Haringey Council’s own reporting shows a consistent and continued failure against both these criteria. The Labour Cabinet seems happy managing a process that produces a big thick report which they either don’t read or don’t understand. The result of Labour’s failure is wasted money, wasted time and a poor outcome for Haringey residents.”

Meeting Ofcom about pirate radio stations

Met with OFCOM earlier today following my raising of the issue of pirate radio stations illegally broadcasting in my area and adversely affecting London Turkish Radio – which is in my constituency.

I can’t go into details about the specifics of what they will be doing to act on this particular issue – but am assured that act they will.

I had a master-class in the issues around radio, bands, enforcement and so on. One issue that sticks up quite clearly is the complete nonsense of the difficulties of catching and raiding illegal stations and the costs involved therein – compared with the ‘punishments’ meted out when someone is caught and convicted.

The average fine is somewhere around £118. There’s nothing wrong with the penalties that can be meted out – they are up to and including two years imprisonment – and other countries treat this seriously and apply such penalties. But for reasons I don’t understand – here the judiciary doesn’t to the same degree. No wonder they’re raided one night and then start up again the very next day. It’s financially still advantageous for them to do so as the fine and the cost of the equipment taken don’t come to anything like the money they make per week – and clearly they have no fear that the court will lock ’em up.

Should I talk to the media off the record?

Story of Ming and Gordon’s siren voice rumble on. I am called by Sky, BBC and Daily Politics to see if I will just have a chat – off the record if I like. Hmmmmmmm – never be fooled by journalists saying they want a chat off the record! And there’s nothing more to say – Gordon wants us. We don’t want him!

PS If you want to know what I think Gordon will be like as Prime Minister – read this.

Liberal Democrats survey residents on Pay-to-Park schemes

Liberal Democrats have set up an on-line survey to monitor views about the Stop-and-Shop parking schemes that have been introduced today in Muswell Hill and Crouch End. The party wants to find out fully what impact these schemes have on the local community.

The Labour Council has been criticised by Lib Dems for imposing these schemes despite overwhelming rejection from the local communities. Questions have also been raised about the cost of ‘unnecessary’ parking surveys in Muswell Hill and Crouch End completed only after the new parking schemes were given the green light by the Council. Figures uncovered by the Lib Dems have shown that the surveys cost a staggering £38,325. The Labour Council has admitted that kerbside space in adjoining residential roads is already at saturation point in both Muswell Hill and Crouch End so just counting the comings and going of cars in this expensive survey just before their scheme is even implemented is meaningless, say Lib Dems.

Cllr Martin Newton, Lib Dem spokesperson on traffic issues comments:

“We have set up an on-line survey to really find out what impact these schemes have on the local community as Labour seem incapable of carrying out any meaningful consultation. What is important is to ask traders, visitors and residents about the impact of the scheme when this is operational. Has there been a change in perception over parking from visitors and residents?What impact has there been on local businesses?”

Cllr Lyn Weber (Crouch End) adds:

“I was astonished when I found out the cost of the most recent Council survey. But more worrying is that the Council told us from the outset that surveys had been done to study the traffic in the area. If these were done why do they need to be done again? This money could have been used more fruitfully by mending the countless number of holes in Haringey’s roads or planting new trees.”