Gordon Brown as PM: good, bad or indifferent?

This Gordon Brownweek’s Liberal Democrat News carries my latest column – and it’s about how Gordon Brown might turn out as Prime Minister:

When I was first elected to Parliament, I looked forward to meeting and seeing in action close up our major politicians, many of whom had previously only been a face on the TV to me.

But Gordon Brown has been strangely absent from my Parliamentary experience. Despite having a huge influence that strays well beyond the Treasury, he rarely debates, rarely answers questions and even in his own Treasury patch leaves most of the Parliamentary speaking to his junior ministers.

You can read the rest of the piece on my website.

Decision made on new school

Well thank goodness! The Schools Adjudicator has decided that the new school in Haringey will be run by the LEA (Local Education Authority). At the three public meetings I personally went to, it was clear that the LEA with their bid for a community school won the support of politicians from both parties (there are only Lib Dems and Labour councillors and MPs in Haringey – no Tories); the entire schools and education community; and also the local parents and residents.

It would have been a travesty of unprecedented scale had the decision gone the other way.

So – the Labour Government’s plot to foist unwanted school business franchises on Haringey with the first of its kind bidding competition has failed. Hoorah!

Gordon Brown

So – it’s to be a coronation! Guess the clunking fist from the future Prime Minister and the spineless consent from the ranks of Labour MPs (the same spineless ones that voted through the war) will deny members their say, the party a proper debate and Gordon a mandate.

It would have been so much better if David Miliband or Charles Clarke or anyone had had the balls to fight Gordon. Even John McDonnell would have been better than nothing and no one. It feels wrong and will do so unless and until there is a General Election. And Gordon (middle name cautious) is unlikely to go for it immediately. Unless he really is new Gordon!

Gordon’s first (and only) hustings saw him present himself as ‘new’ Gordon, for a ‘new’ Britain, with ‘new’ ideas and ‘new’ challenges, etc. etc. ‘Scuse me for thinking he was the bloke what was there all along, hiding head below parapet whilst signing the cheques. Iraq, tuition fees, cutting benefits for the disabled, tube privatisation, and on and on. He was there, at the centre of power, all the time. Not so new Gordon!

What can we expect under Gordon? More announcement, re-announcements and then announcement for a third time of the same pots of money – and a dark, brooding, master pulling the central strings from behind closed doors. I hope I’m wrong, but …

Fortismere School's future

Tonight is the meeting on the way forward for Fortismere School, to which my colleague Cllr Gail Engert is going on behalf of the Lib Dems (as I can’t go) and putting forward our proposals.

There is a great deal of angst and bad feeling grown up in response to the school’s seeming desire to move to foundation status. The concerns are around moves to selection; reduction in intake of statemented children; and changing the criteria to enter the sixth form to only those students attaining A or B grades. People are worried that it will cause disharmony in our community of schools. However, the Government’s policy is to allow such applications.

There are, as I said, very strong views against the proposals – and yet a seeming determination from Head and Governors to go forward. The consultation is coming to a close. I asked the school to at least hold an all-parent ballot – but they have refused at this point in time.

So, what is to be done? What the Liberal Democrats have proposed is a five-point plan:

1) The closing date for the consultation should be extended and the consultation should be widely publicised in order to gather the views of the whole local community.

2) The Head and the Director of Education should meet urgently to try to resolve the conflict between the school and the Council. I’ve offered to facilitate the meeting in the hope that a way forward can be found that avoids the school pushing for foundation status.

3) The school should hold a proper public meeting to allow all points of view to be presented to parents and local community.

4) The school should be transparent and undertake to publish all the results of its informal consultation.

5) The Head and Governors should make their intentions on selection clear – and guarantee Fortismere remains a school for the whole community.

Gail’s comment for the press on this issue was, “Our five point plan ensures that all groups are properly consulted on the future of this successful school and that the results of the consultation are fully transparent. This school is a fundamental part of the local community and decisions on its future direction should take their concerns fully into account.”

Whilst I said, “It is clear that there has been a breakdown in communications between the school and Haringey Council, which has resulted in Fortismere pushing for foundation status. I want Fortismere and Haringey to resolve their differences and start working together for the benefit of parents and the local community. I have offered to broker a meeting between the two sides so we can resolve this dispute. I am hopeful that this issue can be resolved if all sides focus on what is important – the future of the school and the children.”

Litter spotting in Highgate

First Lynne Featherstone MP spotting litter in Highgate Wood with the children from Avenue Nursery, Highgatething visited Avenue Nursery in Highgate. Definitely the Rolls Royce of nurseries – and in fact, not just a nursery, but going up to 6/7 year olds now. Beautiful premises (good design) and facilities (amazingly huge garden)! I am there to accompany a class on a litter observation outing. So eight youngsters, their two teachers and myself and Ed Butcher (councillor and my Head of Office) headed for Highgate Woods.

The children had clipboards with a sheet where they would mark up and tally how many pieces of litter they found. Cans, cigarette butts, plastic bits, sweet wrappers and so on. One sheet was for Highgate Wood – and the other sheet was for Highgate Station car park and then the Archway Road up to Highgate Wood.

Well – the car park and the walk up Archway gave the children a feast of possible litter. We examined cigarette butt after cigarette butt – and whilst in the Highgate tube station car park they wanted to know what an MP was. So I was explaining that the House of Commons was where laws were made and that recently we made a law which will stop people smoking in doors etc.

I congratulated them on their environmental work. They were bright as buttons – and they said why weren’t there any bins? So we decided that they are going to write to me (or email me officially as constituents) and I will then take it up with the relevant authorities and try and get more bins. I did explain that station bins had virtually disappeared for security reasons – but there’s plenty more places they could be put.

Then we arrived at Highgate Wood. What a contrast. Whereas the children were excited every two seconds by various horrible bits of litter before we got to the woods – in the woods we were hard put to find anything. So huge congratulations to the woods keepers for a fantastic job – and to those who use the woods who clearly respect their absolutely beautiful surroundings.

So – definitely one of my pleasantest duties this week – and fun too. And very heart warming to see how dead keen the kids were and how much they learned from this practical action. I am sure they will get another environmental award to add to the two they already have. If only all nurseries could be this good!

Brown on Darfur

I notice that Gordon in his hustings yesterday defended the principle of overseas military intervention in Darfur – saying that he wanted to see a joint UN / African Union force in the country almost immediately. Well – yes – don’t we all? But we are being taken for fools by the Khartoum government who clearly think they can play with us with no consequences. So – this is a test for Gordon: is he an action man or is it just talk, talk?

Sienna Miller and Alastair Campbell

The Lynne Featherstone MP with Nick Clegg and some of the Liberal Democrat Haringey councillors at our local social eventbig local fundraising social of the year took place in my home today. Our star guest was Nick Clegg (Lib Dem Shadow Home Secretary). A huge turnout – partly ‘cos Nick is a big draw and also partly because eleven would-be GLA candidates competing for selection on the list came to lobby for votes. (The party is currently selecting its candidates for the next London elections, and as this is done by a postal ballot of party members the wannabes are busy going round to lots and lots of local events at the moment).

Several local members put together a fantastic array of food (which is the real reason this annual event is so popular) and Nick gave a brilliant summation of where we are and where we need to be going.

In his introduction he obviously talked about our time working together in the Home Affairs team – and in describing me – he said I was a mix between Sienna Miller and Alastair Campbell! I was flattered by only one of these – your call as to which one!

Sadly two pieces of bad news today too. One of our long-serving activists and committed party members, Roderick Benziger died after a long illness. Roderick was one of the very first people to kind of believe in me and give me the confidence and courage to go forward. This never stopped us arguing over a range of issues as Roderick was a thinker and liked nothing better than a good political argument in the pub after any of our activities. From high politics to whether FOCUS should be ready-folded or on gold paper! I was so sad. Particularly as having spent seven months or so at the Whittington, he was finally moved to a nursing home only very recently (which his partner Diana had had to fight tooth and nail to even get him in) and I suppose I was hoping that he would have time and peace to make some sort of recovery. But it wasn’t to be. All the Lib Dems and I send Diana our condolences and love. Roderick was held in great affection by all of us.

The other bad news is the stabbing of a police officer who was working at the front counter of Wood Green police station. A young man jumped over the counter and stabbed the officer in the stomach. The officer is recovering in hospital and a fifteen year old has been arrested. What on earth was the motivation? Was it revenge for some grudge against the police? Was it drugs? When I spoke to the police – obviously it was too early to know any of those aspects but it does remind us abruptly and forcefully just what the police can have to face. Best wishes to the officer who wishes to remain anonymous at present for a speedy recovery.

UPDATE: Duncan Borrowman and Jonathan Fryer have now blogged about the Nick Clegg event too.

Hearing the Highgate Choral Society

On Saturday evening it was off to a concert by the Highgate Choral Society at St Joseph’s Church (Highgate Hill). Apart from some Christmas choral concerts at St John’s in Smith Square, choral music hasn’t been my musical place – despite having such wonderful local groups as this one and the Crouch End Festival Chorus.

But – I was invited to become a patron of the Highgate Choral Society, so it was off to attend the concert to see and support them. And it was absolutely wonderful. The first piece was Haydn’s Nelson Mass – which was soaring and uplifting. The second piece (which everyone warned me was ‘challenging’ and not at all ‘traditional’) I really liked. It was ‘modern’ by choral standards – and the composer, Paul Patterson (who is a Highgate residents) was actually there. In eight parts, it veered from discordant to melodic and dramatic.

The choir itself must have numbered eighty or so people – plus there was the New London Orchestra, four soloists and Ronald Corp conducting. All in all, a great local evening and the church was absolutely packed out with hundreds of people.

What does a young person have to do in Haringey?

Gail Lynne Featherstone MP with Gail Engert and the local police team at the Muswell Hill and Highgate Area AssemblyEngert (Muswell Hill councillor / Lib Dem) had a fantastic idea. Haringey’s Area Assemblies are a good thing in theory – but the same people tend to come each time and it often ends up as the Council presenting rather than the ‘you talk, we listen’ promise that Labour Haringey said these meeting would be.

So – Gail (who now chairs the Muswell Hill and Highgate Assembly) had the idea of having it in a marquee right in the middle of Albert Road Recreation Ground and focusing it on young people and families.

So there were stalls – which gave out information on all the projects – and there was a section for young children to play in – so lots of parents with toddlers were able to come for once. And there was a seating section for the formal part of the meeting. And it was on a Saturday afternoon – not a weekday night.

It’s a shame that the weather wasn’t better – but attendance was pretty good and it wasn’t just the usual people there. But with all the relevant departments there to inform local people about every aspect of youth services the pity was, as one woman said, that Haringey Council really doesn’t publicise these things in a way to get new people in and more people in. There weren’t even leaflets through very local peoples’ doors. I know Haringey Council does a bit – but not nearly enough – though of course the local Liberal Democrats do put efforts into publicising the area assemblies too (and when occasionally for one reason or another we haven’t done our bit, it has shown in the lower than usual attendance).

There were a few very short informative presentations and then they had a panel including Shayan and Adam (our co-chairs of Haringey Youth Council) on a panel and some officers and councillors to answer questions from the attendees. And the sort of points made were spot on:

– there’s nothing for my son and his friends to do around here
– the PFI improvements to schools mean that the halls that used to be rented free or cheaply to local groups like scouts and woodcraft folk have been priced out the market
– there is real anti-social behaviour (it’s not just perception)

You get the gist. The positives are that there is a program of activity for young people, a summer university and a discount card for young people in Haringey – but I really don’t think that they get out into the community and the schools in the west of the borough in the way they do in the east. That was reflected by members of the audience who raised it too.

There had been quite a lot of trouble at Alexandra Park Library and originally in the recreation ground too, but I was talking to the (police) Safer Neighbourhood Team before the meeting itself started and it was clear that they were working their way into being recognised by and having a relationship with the ring-leaders. As with most of this stuff – it is just a very few young people who make life a misery for others.

One good idea from elsewhere – the Bounds Green Safer Neighbourhood Team did some youth football etc last summer and now have a ward football team, Bounds Green United. So perhaps that’s something the Alexandra ward team could look at – and perhaps even all the wards so that there is a ward football league?

So – lots more effort needed. Make sure that the kids who say they have nothing to do are engaged and informed and brought in to what there is to do. Re-open Muswell Hill Centre full time – that seems bloody obvious. Young people are generally good – but if there’s nothing to do – well they hang around and…

Talking to one young man who was in the middle of a survey of young people, he made a strong argument for not simply creating (as if they would) facilities in each location. There is a lot of ‘territorial’ problems where young people won’t go into others’ territories for fear of trouble – and he argued out that the creation of separate facilities would simply make those divides even greater. So – perhaps we also need to work on keeping the territorial issues to sporting contests – rather than potential gang warfare.

Anyway – congrats to Gail for thinking up such a new approach to Area Assemblies.