Jerry Springer: The Opera DVD – news from Sainsbury's

It’s a small, small world – it turns out Sainsbury’s Director of Communications lives in my constituency – and has some views about the Jerry Springer DVD controversy!

The background first. The various campaigns against Sainsbury’s and Woolworths over their decision to pull the Jerry Springer: The Opera DVD from sale are gathering quite a head of steam – and both supermarkets seem to be feeling the heat.

Sainsbury’s first apparently told The Independent it has only received ten complaints before deciding to withdraw the DVD.

In subsequent media coverage this was upped to 10-20 complaints though outside the BBC and The Independent all the coverage seems to have been on blogs – most of the mainstream media have missed the story so far. That may be about to change as the actors’ union Equity have taken up the case too.

My favourite complaint to Sainsbury’s is The Customer is Always Right’s: – Jim Davidson and Rabelais in the same email – not often you see that!

So – what do Sainsbury’s now say? Well, their Director of Communications (Pip Wood) says they received “hundreds” of complaints, the DVD was selling badly and would have been withdrawn from sale anyway. The complaints just speeded it up.

This leaves some interesting question – where did the 10 and then 10-20 figures come from, and why were they left out there for so long? And why was the initial coverage all about how Sainsbury’s had been responding to customer complaints? Of course the media don’t always get stories completely right – but then why was none of this either given in the various replies from their customer services that people received either? Could it be that they realised they’ve blundered and are looking for a way out … ?

As for Woolworths, they’re now saying – “The product is not currently available in stores, however should a customer wish to purchase it, it is available from our website.” Looks like they’re trying to back out of their earlier decision a bit … especially as they’re now telling the press that they didn’t pull it after all because of complaints – see the PA story

So – in summary, keep the letters and emails going I think! More on this in my earlier Jerry Springer: The Opera DVD blog post.

Meeting Santa and drawing prizes

I get to welcome Santa at the YMCA 2005 Dance Show held at St Mary’s School. The YMCA does a lot for kids in our area. It’s a shame that Haringey Council doesn’t count them as a partner and help their work – as it is one of the organisations that actually does something about giving youngsters alternatives to misbehaviour. Sadly, Haringey Council does not seem particularly interested in these sort of alternatives. The YMCA also recently set up a nursery for single mums – really fantastic – and organises the annual Fun Run!

Anyway – back to the dance show. An extraordinary number of children took part – aged about 4 -18 I would guess. Lots and lots and lots of short dances ranging from modern to ballet to tap and street dance. Kids on. Kids off. Gorgeous and talented. My kids are too old now to do shows at their school – but I remember crying every year when they used to. There is something so pure and so wonderful about kids performing. And the talent on show – absolutely unbelievable.

The pianist for the first section was introduced – Krystyna Budzynska. I thought that name sounds familiar – well you would wouldn’t you?

So at the end I go on stage to welcome Santa. I hear music, Santa must be coming … and we wait – and wait. The chap who told me what to do suggested that as the music played I should leave the stage – but Santa was still sorting himself out. Eventually he arrived and distributed presents to all the children who took part.

And as I left the stage and passed the piano, I said to the pianist, “Did you go to South Hampstead?” She looked at me and said, “Lynne? Lynne Ryness?” We had been in the same class and hadn’t seen each other for about 35 years! Now that was really lovely.

In the late afternoon I set out for Kingston where I am doing the Liberal Democrats Christmas Prize Draw at a dinner. The Christmas Prize Draw is one of the big fund-raisers for the Lib Dems and is a national one with really fantastic prizes. There are 50 prizes to be drawn for. It takes me two hours to get there. I drive because I know I will be coming home late – and then remember why I hate driving in London! The dinner is very pleasant and Ed Davey – the local Lib Dem MP – comes over at the end of the meal to say he will introduce me and then I will speak.

So I did. And then the hard work began. The tubs holding upwards of 45,000 tickets were deep – and I needed to be sure that I took from every corner of all three containers and at every depth! After the first 30 or so (which happily did seem to cover the length and breadth of Britain) – I decided that Ed should do some work and handed over to him for the last 20. It only took and hour and a quarter coming back. Partly less traffic – but coming back is always quicker than going doncha find?

Quernmore Road

Really pleased to see that my Lib Dem colleague, Cllr Laura Edge (Stroud Green ward), is doing some stirling local work on a mural for Quernmore Road. It follows on from the work I did with her to improve the local railway station when I was on the London Assembly. I eventually managed to get the station surrounds improved with new bins, fencing and cleared dumped rubbish. The mural and other she is doing are great project – well done Laura!

Christmas lunch

Outside of surgery this morning not a lot to report as I took my staff (from both constituency and Parliament offices) out for Christmas lunch (yes – a long lunch).

They have really coped superbly in an office that is mega-busy. And we have all been on a steep learning curve – but what is really great is everyone gets on and it is a good-natured office – which under the stresses and strains of the nature of such an office is just fab!

Hornsey Central Hospital

Early morning meeting with Richard Sumray, Chair of Haringey Primary Care Trust (PCT). I have asked him to come and update me on the proposed development of Hornsey Central Hospital. It is now years since I joined local campaigners to campaign against the closure of the old hospital and then with local campaigners to ensure that a community health facility replaced what was lost.

Richard had been hoping to have a public meeting in December but this is now delayed until January because the relevant policy paper has not yet gone to the trust’s Board and won’t do now until January. The proposed scheme – the Primary Care Resource Centre, the Healthy Living centre and other health functions yet to be decided by the practitioners – is still on but there are still some big stumbling blocks remaining before the project can proceed. The second floor of the 2nd Stage, which was to provide offices, hit a dead end when it became clear that the costs were too high. The Strategic Health Trust rejected the project as it was thought to be unaffordable. Since then Richard Sumray and the Board have been re-examining the whole project for ways of making it more affordable and therefore viable.

The redevelopment is being funded through the Government’s LIFT scheme, which means involving a private partner. The PCT consulted their private partner over the idea that the private partner take on the risk of the top floor – developing it for themselves. This would theoretically make it financially feasible, and mean that there were no major changes to the amount of health services to be provided. However, there are risks. The PCT is pretty desperate to get the plans for Hornsey Hospital finished and through by March, because otherwise they will be left with a large financial deficit at the start of the next financial year. But because of the huge level of bureaucracy involved in LIFT schemes it is even money as to whether they will make it.

In the afternoon I am see an ‘informant’. Since my days on the Met Police Authority (MPA) I have been pursuing the use of DNA in the search for an abhorrent rapist. The crimes – against old women – are an abomination and have been going on for around ten years with no success by the police in capturing the criminal.

However, in recent years the police have been trawling the black community for ‘voluntary’ DNA samples. These samples have not, in my view, been voluntary at all. 125 refusniks received an intimidatory letter from a senior detective saying that he was going to look into their reasons for refusal and then let them know of his decision. Well – if it was voluntary – no need to look into anything or decide anything. Furthermore, five of those written to continued to refuse and in the end were arrested. Two gave in at that point, and the remaining three arrested had their DNA taken – as once arrested it is compulsory.

It is so easy to say end justifies means. It is easy to see the argument that this crime is so horrific that it is right to take DNA voluntarily or otherwise. Don’t get me wrong. The police are doing a great job. But it is a complete misnomer to call this type of testing ‘voluntary’. It is clearly mandatory in practice. And if mandatory DNA testing is happening, that should only be after a proper debate results in a decision to change the rules – we shouldn’t get mandatory testing introduced by the back door. Balancing civil rights, personal freedoms and the fight against crime are tricky – which is all the more reasons why such decisions should not happen on the quiet and without proper public debate.

Since then the trail had gone somewhat cold – for me. The police still hadn’t caught the culprit. Then I got an email from someone who only recently was pulled in to give a sample on a spurious excuse and refused. He said he couldn’t put it all in an email – so today he came into see me. And he had quite a tale to tell. Needless to say – I will be pursuing this as soon as I have put together an appropriate strategy to so do. It was extremely disheartening to hear some of the treatment he encountered.

Ironically, I then dash over to Earls Court for the Met Police Authority’s Christmas do! Very nice to see everyone again. I do miss the MPA – however being LibDem spokesperson on Police, Crime and Disorder and Prisons at least keeps me in the right portfolio.

BOOST FOR LOCAL FIRST-TIME BUYERS AS LIB DEMS FORCE GOVERNMENT U-TURN IN TAX BREAKS FOR BUY-TO-LET INVESTORS

Hornsey and Wood Green Lib Dem MP Lynne Featherstone has claimed victory for local residents after Gordon Brown performed an astonishing u-turn in the House of Commons on Monday.

Following pressure from Liberal Democrat MPs, Mr Brown admitted defeat and changed the rules relating to Self Invested Pension Plans (SIPPS) which, if left untouched, could have led to rocketing house prices in Hornsey and Wood Green as wealthy investors purchased buy-to-let homes with pension tax breaks.

In 2004 the Government relaxed the rules on SIPPS which meant that people could purchase a property, put it into a pension product known as a SIPP, and then receive a generous 40 per cent tax break. The rules were meant to start in April 2006, but have now been scrapped in line with Liberal Democrat proposals tabled in June.

Commenting Lynne Featherstone said:

“This is great news for those wishing to climb on to the housing ladder in London boroughs such as Haringey. We all know that flats and houses in Haringey are an extremely attractive prospect for wealthy investors so I am delighted our campaign has forced the Government’s hand.

“Offering investors a 40 per cent tax break to buy a rental home here could have priced ordinary people in Hornsey and Wood Green out of the market completely. What we need in Hornsey and Wood Green is good quality, affordable housing that is available to those who live and work in the community.

“I am delighted that concerted Liberal Democrat pressure has shown the Government the error of their ways. Of course this just the tip of the iceberg when it comes to securing affordable housing, but at least the Chancellor’s u-turn offers people in urban areas like Hornsey and Wood Green some protection.”

LIB DEM GAIL BACKS BID TO HELP KIDS GET ACTIVE AT BREAK-TIMES

Lib Dem Haringey Education Spokesperson Cllr Gail Engert has called on Haringey Council to help children to play games at break-times by painting game markings on a local school’s playground. The calls come after children raised the issue during one of Cllr Engert’s regular visits to the school earlier this month.

They informed Cllr Engert that the School Council had written to Haringey Council to request a range of markings on the playground from football to hopscotch. Cllr Engert offered to put her weight behind the campaign and wrote to the Council asking them to address the children’s request.

Cllr Engert was impressed at the children’s initiative in seeking these playground improvements. She says she will be pressing for action as it is essential that kids are encouraged to be active at break-times and anything that helps them should be done.

Cllr Engert (Muswell Hill) comments:

“I am delighted to see young people using their initiative and writing to the Council about this issue and I am more than happy to assist them.

“With the cross-party interest in keeping children healthy, I hope that Haringey Council assist the school in helping the kids keep active!”

LIB DEMS TACKLE COLERIDGE SCHOOL ISSUE

Haringey Lib Dems have responded to the Haringey Council’s statutory consultation on future plans for Coleridge School, calling for full and transparent consultation, robust planning and risk assessment, as well as a traffic assessment that addresses all safety concerns.

Lib Dem councillor for Crouch End, Ron Aitken made the response to the consultation following meetings with a number of local residents and parent groups from both sides of the argument along with Lynne Featherstone MP

In the response Cllr Aitken expresses the Lib Dems’ deep concern at Haringey Council’s failure to plan for future demographic growth in Crouch End and the surrounding area.

He highlights that as recently as 1988 the Labour-controlled Council closed a perfectly adequate School in Crouch End (Highgate Wood Lower School in Park Road/Wolseley Road) and attempted, unsuccessfully, to sell it to Waitrose. It was eventually sold for housing following a fire at the site.

The Lib Dems acknowledge the importance of resolving this situation, particularly for the parents of the children expecting a place on the Coleridge/ TUC site for 2006, and have asked the Council to ensure provisions are made for this year.

However, the Lib Dems emphasise that the long-term solution must be reached with a thorough consultation and the full results and comments published so that parents can see how the decision was made.

Both Cllr Aitken and Lynne Featherstone MP acknowledge that the conclusion reached by the Council may not please everyone, but they say that the Lib Dems will fight to ensure that the Council addresses and investigates the concerns of all interested parties thoroughly.

Cllr Aitken (Crouch End) comments:

“Haringey Council has a poor record on consultation and I think this is adding to the concerns of local parents. The Lib Dems aim to ensure that all sides are heard and that a solution is achieved which involves the community as a whole and addresses the long-term needs of children in Haringey.”

Cllr Lynne Featherstone, MP adds:

“If parents and local residents are properly consulted and the best solution put forward as a result – then we can all unite around that solution. If parents and local residents feel that the consultation is not genuine or rushed – then the risk will be a divided community. Haringey must do this properly so that the vital school places that everyone wants are provided in the best possible way.”

LIB DEMS UNCOVER TRUE COST OF HARINGEY PEOPLE MAGAZINE

Lib Dem Leader of the Opposition on Haringey Council, Cllr Neil Williams, has expressed his concern after the Lib Dems uncovered figures that show the annual cost of producing the Haringey Council’s magazine, Haringey People, is in excess of £450,000.

The Council figures were revealed to the Liberal democrats following an enquiry into current costs after Haringey Council proposed an additional increase of £165,000 to cover the postage cost of the monthly publication.

The Council disclosed that budget cost for design, print and distribution of Haringey People is £294,600. With the additional cost of postage pushes the final figure to £458,400. It is unclear whether this cost includes staffing, and the Lib Dems are investigating.

The Lib Dems feel that with Haringey Council under pressure on many vital services, they have little excuse to spend almost £500,000 of local taxpayers’ money on a glossy campaigning magazine.

Cllr Williams says that the magazine should not be about Labour Councillors and David Lammy, but should solely be a publication that gives useful information to residents about issues that concern them.

Cllr Williams (Highgate) comments:

“I am very concerned that local people are having to pay hundreds of thousands of pounds on what the Council sometimes uses as a Labour campaigning tool.

“If the Lib Dems take control we will be looking to overhaul the magazine and make it into something that gives better value and is more useful to local residents.”

STROUD GREEN: LIB DEM LAURA BACKS CAMPAIGN TO FIGHT W5 REROUTING

Lib Dem councillor for Stroud Green Laura Edge has joined with local residents in Chettle Court and the surrounding area to object to plans by London Buses to reroute the W5 bus to take out the loop past Harringay Station, N4.

Cllr Edge delivered a letter to London Buses along with a petition signed by over one hundred bus users and people living on the loop which was arranged by a resident in Chettle Court assisted by Cllr Edge and local Lib Dem activists.

The loop diverts the bus off Oakfield Road via Stapleton Hall Road, past Harringay Station before rejoining Oakfield Road. London Buses believe there is little demand for the loop and removing it will make the route faster.

However in her letter Cllr Edge expresses her deep concern at the poor quality of consultation carried out by London Buses and says that they are overlooking the value of the service to local residents in the area, many of whom are elderly, disabled or have young children and rely on the hail and ride service as it provides easier access to local amenities and the Whittington Hospital.

She is also concerned that many of the W5 bus drivers are already missing the loop out if no-one on the bus requires any of the stops – leaving those on the loop waiting for longer periods.

Cllr Edge (Stroud Green) comments:

“At a time when Londoners are being told to use public transport it seems counter-productive to break this valuable link. I hope that this letter and petition demonstrate the clear opposition to the plans and makes London Buses reconsider.”